OK, so review of the knives I purchased last week:
1) Leatherman Skeletool – Meh. Think of it like a bare bones Charge: smaller and less tools, but only the tools you’d actually use. The selling point is also its main drawback. The smaller size doesn’t fit my hand very well, but it also has most of the tools I would need in an EDC multi-tool, including a nice, sharp knife, pliers, screwdriver with interchangeable bits, and a bottle opener/caribiner. Because of the fit, I don’t see myself using it every day
2) Gerber Hook Safety knife – Avoid. The design was cool but in the end it’s not a very practical tool for carrying around. The little sheath and clip are extremely tight
3) Kershaw Scrabler – Good, but with drawbacks. Very nice looking knife, extremely sharp. Possibly too nice for an EDC…I’d hate to scratch it up! The main drawbacks are a matter of preference. There’s no thumb stud, so the only way to open it is with the speed assist on the back of the blade. Another feature I’ll have to get used to is the pocket clip is mounted on the bottom of the handle instead of the top. It might not sound like a big deal, but most blades are built the other way around, so it feels strange when you try to put it back into your pocket and the clip isn’t where you thought it would be. The final drawback is the safety release is on the handle instead of on the inside. While I’m not worried about it collapsing while I’m using it, it’s sort of a pain to close the blade if you are gripping the handle too hard.