*note-this is not the response I had posted earlier. Somehow, something I said was transcribed over what I typed.
so here goes, albeit, a much shorter version. I think we misunderstood each other. I was commenting on the number of police in the country and pointing out that your figure was incorrect. I can’t recall the exact discussion, but I imagine something along the lines of a sarcastic “only a few bad apples.”
I have a masters in Crim and I look at many of these cases or topics in law enforcement and begin devising some kind of research that could answer these questions. I honestly can’t come up with much of a design that could ever cover the good cop v bad cop ratio. Besides a “how satisfied are you with the job your police are doing?” Which is the weakest most subjective method out there. We simply have no way to compile the data. One method of data gathering would be to make a department or branch of the government that collects stats such as number of arrests, % of arrests involving force, number of police shootings where subject lived vs died, and the number of interactions with citizens daily. I read somewhere that out of the hundreds of thousands of on duty officers every day, there are millions of law enforcement encounters with citizens such as traffic stops, RAS stops, calls for service, etc. you could get stats that could tell you out of the millions of interactions daily, how many lead to arrest, how many involved force, how many shootings? It’s still not telling the whole story, but it’s a start. This would require every police officer to co plate an fbi form every shift for every officer and then someone to crunch those monster sized numbers.
Then you get into the extremely subjective “what makes a good vs bad cop” which does nothing for us, so we are stuck with random sampling polls and stats that don’t tell the whole story. You get a flat number of people killed by police each year, which is broken into the all important black vs white stats that show police are 2.5 times more likely to shoot a black man than a white man even though whites account for higher numbers as would be expected. What those numbers don’t take Into account is whether the subject was armed and their actions, so again, pretty much useless without further numbers. Maybe that government agency I spoke of goes back and checks “justified or not” after the investigation is complete.