I think you have valid points it just difficult to figure out how legit some of these guys are. I’ve seen guys come on the show with records like 19-3 and look like complete ass.
I can’t even tell you how many forum debates and deep discussions take place over deciphering resumes like Khabibs pre ufc. It’s not straight forward and it’s not all one in the same. It’s very very very hard to tell how well someone will do until they perform against ufc opponents.
Yes we have guys who come on and it feels like a waste of time. Others, it seems like a waste of time and then they turn out to be….less than ideal.
It’s just so hard to say who’s the khabib, and who’s the guy that’s you know….not. Because opponent skill level does matter SO much. Until these guys fight known commodities it’s almost impossible to discern their career trajectories.
Here's a list of dudes who were obvious direct-signees in the era before WME/DWCS/ESPN finding a new way to create cheap content (the network that loves NCAA unpaid sports and makes more money from NFL draft coverage than the actual players drafted do).
3 guys from this week alone to start (will edit as I go through the season). None of these guys needed the contender series to show us they were prospects/capable of being legit UFC fights who could win in the league, let alone be worthy of losing in the UFC. They're either famous Americans with few fights, or dominant foreigners the UFC has a tough time selling as direct hires to dumb espn casuals.
Episode 10
-Bo Nickal (nuff said. Had bigger televised matches than all UFC fighters besides headliners)
-Rafel Estevam 10-0 Nova Uniao trained. Last 6 wins vs guys w/ winning records. Had just come off a 1st rd finish of an undefeated prospect in LFA and a 10-1 prospect right before that
Mateus Mendonca- Training partner to a UFC champ at legendary chuteboxe. 10-0. Wins. Last fight was a win over a 21-5 guy with UFC experience (who got cut for no reason besides being brazilian and fighting a NC lol). Finished almost every fight.
Episode 9:
Bruno Ferreira- All finishes, undefeated, all recent wins vs experienced vets with winning record.
Nurullo Aliev- Undefeated 22 year old beast. Also plenty of wins against vets with winning record.
Jafel Filho - 14-2 Nova Uniao. 2 losses to good opponent. Finishes against a bunch of experienced guys.
Episode 8:
Farid Basharat - Undefeated; brother also UFC prospect. Forced to fight a really good brazilian prospect for whatever reason. Both could have fought in the UFC for more money for the same fight.
Ikram Aliskerov- Only loss to to Chimaev. Fought in top Russian leagues. Sambo world champ. Tooled on his overmatched opponent who was brought back to lose.
Episode 7:
Bonfim Brothers- 13-0 and 18-3. Tons of wins over winning vets. Smaller brother forced to fight a very skilled 30 fight vet in Abbasov. These guys were fighting Adriano Moraes and Moicano literally 10 years ago. But somehow need to prove they belong in the UFC by fighting for 5k against some 6 fight guy who started pro fighting after Covid started?
Episode 6:
Mateysz Rebecki 16-1 coming off a 5 round title fight win. 9 years as a pro. Wins over guys who are current KSW champ and multiple guys 10-3 or better.
Episode 4:
Claudio Ribeiro: 10-2. Coming off 5th rd title finish. losses to legit guys. Needed to somehow prove he was worthy by early-stoppage clipping a terrible flailer in the DWCS; no bonus for brutal KO win.
Nazim Sadyhkhov- Serra Longo protege. A little green, but would have been the next Nick Catone at least; prolly weakest on the list.
Episode 3:
Bo Nickal again
Erik Silva- 35 9-1 All finishes, flashy style. Legit opponents. Dude has like 3 good years left. No fucking point.
Episode 2:
Billy Goff- Last win prior to DWCS was against a DWCS guy lol. Lost a 5 round war in his 3rd ever pro fight against a UFC and Bellator vet in Lachinov. Only non foreigner that seems to have already had a legit record.
Vinicius De Almeida Salvador. 14-4. Losses to other brazilian studs including Filho who is on this same list. Exciting style. 9 years experience.
It's a total joke, and their scouting/matchmaking department is basically just pretend theatre. Each of these dudes would be favored by bookmakers in a real full UFC fight unless paired with a ranked fighter, and yet they're all now getting 5k/5k to start in 2022 because of the contract-manipulations of creating a Contender Series as the way ugly looking foreigners are forced to enter the UFC.
This list of 15 guys alone is saving the UFC about $500,000 in wages, benefits, and bonuses from just one fight each being turned from a regular-contract UFC debut that guys used to get, to BS DWCS terms debut.