Shogun or Wand? Who was the best LHW in Pride? I feel like Pride pushed Wand a bit more b/c he held the belt.
Also, was Shogun a smallish LHW? I know he was thick but he always seem a bit small compared to some of the other dudes.
Excellent question! My two favorite fighters or all time.
Right of the bat the question favors Wanderlei because he was in Pride longer, earlier and had the ability to establish himself as a dominant champion.
Wanderlei was in Pride from 99 to 2007, spanning 8 years. LHW record of 21-2. Was MW champ from 2001 to 2007 and defended his title 3 times. Won the 2003 MW GP. Notable wins over Hendo, Arona, Rampage 2x, Sakuraba 3x, Mezger, and Kaz Nakamura.
Shogun spent 3.5 years in Pride and had a record of 12-0, only two decisions. Won the 2005 MW GP and had notable wins over Rampage, Arona, Rogerio, Overeem 2x, Randleman and Kaz Nakamura.
Now, based on accomplishments I gotta go with Wanderlei. He just accomplished more because of the timing, he spent twice as many years in Pride and had twice as many fights. He had the opportunity to establish himself as champion.
But the question was who was the best LHW. And in my opinion I have to say Shogun. If we look at common opponents in Rampage and Arona, Shogun pretty clearly dominated those guys more than Wand. While Wand did TKO Rampage twice, he did have some problems with Rampage while Shogun blasted him early. And Wand went 1-1 with Arona, while Shogun destroyed him. Wand TKO'd Nak while Shogun won by decision. Shogun showed a better overall MMA game IMO, not only a striking threat but also a grappling threat.
As mentioned Wand did have more wins and title defenses. But I think its pretty safe to assume if it was Shogun in that time fighting the same opponents, Shogun would do just as well. I think just based on how dominant Shogun was at 205 in those 12 fights makes him the best LHW.
About size, Shogun was a good size LHW. He wasn't big or small for the class but just right.
Also, there is the historic fight over the pitbull that has been a legendary story on here. I got the scoop of what actually happened from Wand himself.