- Joined
- Dec 19, 2013
- Messages
- 5,258
- Reaction score
- 437
I agree, though I do think you underestimate the quality of coaching that exists around the US. You have very very technical coaches who are very good at development, they just for whatever reason choose to stay at a local high school or just help out at a club or would rather be the assistant coach at a good program than head coach at an inner city or rural school and deal with paperwork.An important factor to consider is that most BJJ instructors aren't that good at takedowns or teaching them. And if they are, it was usually because they did Judo or wrestled at some point so they tend to teach the way they were taught, and both those arts (in the US at least) are taught in a very smash-mouth, tough-it-out way. When I taught standup specifically for BJJ, I don't know that I every had anyone get hurt because most of what I was doing didn't involve any more impact than getting swept. I mean, if you're teaching BJJ folks who aren't very good at falling big hip throws like you learn in Judo, you're doing it wrong. An ankle pick is a lot better for BJJ competition, and the fall from an ankle pick is nothing. If I am teaching higher impact throws like osoto or kosoto (about the highest impact throws I teach BJJ people), I try to use a crash pad. You simply don't need to have the intensity of a college wrestling practice nor the high impact repertoire of Judo to teach effective TDs for self defense or BJJ competition.
The other thing not accounted for when talking about American coaching is that a lot of the wrestling programs are at public high schools, as in the same teaching methods needed or used to teach and manage a group of 30-50 kids of vastly different ability and intelligence, and who may or may not want to be there in the classroom or practice and may or may not be motivated, are not the same teaching methods used in a club or high level gym or college room with generally higher level, higher motivation, and incentive. I personally know several coaches who make me and much better coaches than me feel like we don't know anything about technique sometimes who coach club or summer practice completely difference than in-season for those reasons (you also have to consider amount of individual attention in each)