- Joined
- Oct 16, 2009
- Messages
- 77,420
- Reaction score
- 12,884
I liked the movie, but i'm not surprised its not doing gangbusters at the box office.
1. The trailers, while appealing to the nerds like me, were objectively not good. And in this era if you can't pull together an amazing trailer its a sign, right or wrong, that the movie doesn't have anything worth sharing.
2. The movie, while again appealing to the nerds like me, just wasn't great. Nobody was telling their IRL friends "you have to see this movies!!". It was just spread too thin and had too man flaws. And I liked it.
The Silver Surfer chase was the best part of the movie, but was overcomplicated by Sue giving birth. The better way to have told the story, was for Galactus to be the one to announce that Sue was pregnant in the first place. Not only is that super creepy, but the movie still proceeds as planned. The birth sequence doesn't take away from the amazing light speed chase around a black hole. It could have been better utilized to highlight Reed's genius ability to calculate a solution, Ben's piloting, and Sue's invisibility. Maybe Johnny's powers could have been used to augment the ship's escape velocity somehow. Now, Sue comes full term back on Earth while the F.F. prepares the world for Galactus, who appears as Sue is giving birth, or just after. Finale goes pretty much as drawn up. Because why the fuck would you fly into space to defend the earth from a world eating force of nature in your 3rd trimester? It would also have spared us some creepy cgi baby.
Johnny Storm should not have been written as a a world class linguist, alternate reality or not. That was just dumb. And if for no other reason than Reed didn't even have enough geniusy things to do in the movie, why divide that aspect of the team and delegate it to Johnny fucking Storm?
The CGI was really inconsistent from bad bad to okay.
It was the right call to not do an origin story, and have it in an alternate past, but having a montage that included "battles" with Red Ghost and the Mad Thinker (neither shown btw)??? then later referencing Diablo, Puppet Master, and The Wizard (none shown)l??? and then insult of insult have a shitty cgi homage to F.F. #1 where Thing clobbers Giganto on a screen in screen job??? C'mon. Such a egregious dropping of the ball. They really needed that scene imo (Giganto vs Mole Man). Not only for the fan service, not only for the proper homage that can not be delivered with proper cgi, but to set up Thing's strength, which they don't really do justice. Like who thought Reed kicking a shitty cgi orangutan in a shitty cgi action sequence was the scene the movie needed and the fans wanted?
And ultimate nit pick. Paul Walter Hauser's Mole Man is the kind of shit you seen in a DVD option for "cut scenes". And I did not like the way they portrayed MM. It was very lazy and unimaginative. I felt they could have even included him in the plot to defeat Galactus by causing a sink hole to trip him into the gizmo thingy.
Still liked it and still plan on seeing it again in theatres, but this is why the movie might wind up being a "failure".
Does like the MCU even know its free to join Sherdog and slip into my DMs for some pro-bono consulting?
1. The trailers, while appealing to the nerds like me, were objectively not good. And in this era if you can't pull together an amazing trailer its a sign, right or wrong, that the movie doesn't have anything worth sharing.
2. The movie, while again appealing to the nerds like me, just wasn't great. Nobody was telling their IRL friends "you have to see this movies!!". It was just spread too thin and had too man flaws. And I liked it.
The Silver Surfer chase was the best part of the movie, but was overcomplicated by Sue giving birth. The better way to have told the story, was for Galactus to be the one to announce that Sue was pregnant in the first place. Not only is that super creepy, but the movie still proceeds as planned. The birth sequence doesn't take away from the amazing light speed chase around a black hole. It could have been better utilized to highlight Reed's genius ability to calculate a solution, Ben's piloting, and Sue's invisibility. Maybe Johnny's powers could have been used to augment the ship's escape velocity somehow. Now, Sue comes full term back on Earth while the F.F. prepares the world for Galactus, who appears as Sue is giving birth, or just after. Finale goes pretty much as drawn up. Because why the fuck would you fly into space to defend the earth from a world eating force of nature in your 3rd trimester? It would also have spared us some creepy cgi baby.
Johnny Storm should not have been written as a a world class linguist, alternate reality or not. That was just dumb. And if for no other reason than Reed didn't even have enough geniusy things to do in the movie, why divide that aspect of the team and delegate it to Johnny fucking Storm?
The CGI was really inconsistent from bad bad to okay.
It was the right call to not do an origin story, and have it in an alternate past, but having a montage that included "battles" with Red Ghost and the Mad Thinker (neither shown btw)??? then later referencing Diablo, Puppet Master, and The Wizard (none shown)l??? and then insult of insult have a shitty cgi homage to F.F. #1 where Thing clobbers Giganto on a screen in screen job??? C'mon. Such a egregious dropping of the ball. They really needed that scene imo (Giganto vs Mole Man). Not only for the fan service, not only for the proper homage that can not be delivered with proper cgi, but to set up Thing's strength, which they don't really do justice. Like who thought Reed kicking a shitty cgi orangutan in a shitty cgi action sequence was the scene the movie needed and the fans wanted?
And ultimate nit pick. Paul Walter Hauser's Mole Man is the kind of shit you seen in a DVD option for "cut scenes". And I did not like the way they portrayed MM. It was very lazy and unimaginative. I felt they could have even included him in the plot to defeat Galactus by causing a sink hole to trip him into the gizmo thingy.
Still liked it and still plan on seeing it again in theatres, but this is why the movie might wind up being a "failure".
Does like the MCU even know its free to join Sherdog and slip into my DMs for some pro-bono consulting?
Last edited: