- Joined
- Aug 15, 2015
- Messages
- 26,650
- Reaction score
- 10
I don't think she's necessarily stupid in this case. You have to admit though this is an area (minimum wage/standard of living) that is a prominent political talking point for her and she's tweeting false information to her followers to get them worked up. That's a pretty sketchy image, when a politician provides false information to make a point about some issue that is dear to them. You can think they're opportunistic liars, stupid, or just made a genuine slip, take your pick. I think there is a very good chance she made a genuine slip and tweeted something she hadn't fully verified, but my thought on that is "Verify before you talk - your voice has lots of people listening to it." I can understand people thinking she's either stupid or a liar though and, frankly, both are possible. She is slowly but surely building a track record for tweeting/saying things that are half truths or outright falsehoods.
As for how we generally react to things like this, consider it. If Trump rambles on about clean coal and then gives an outright false number concerning something related to it that makes coal power look good, we'll call him an outright liar - as it should be. Actually, he does stuff like that all the time and we (rightly) call him either a liar or an idiot for it. Even if we give her the benefit of the doubt, and even if she's not nearly as bad as Trump, I think her repeated gaffes are eyebrow raising. How often does she get to have these gaffes before we take the stance of "can you start double checking that what you're about to tweet is accurate before you say it?" This isn't exactly an isolated incident.
i have stated before that being a partisan hack politician does not necessarily mean someone is stupid. You can disagree with them vehemently but they can be intelligent or stupid.
So many of the things people say 'oh she said something stupid' are based on them disagreeing in a partisan way and wanting to label the elements of that disagreement as stupid which , again is just very partisan.
I don't agree with many elements of the Green New Deal but others are not automatically stupid to agree with elements I do not. To simply say 'oh she believes that... ergo stupid' is just wrong.
Look at the stuff I quoted above that Trump said. It requires no partisan spin. And also no partisan spin can save it. It is just stupid on his face. That is why I saw you can post the quote and do not need to give your own explanation or spin as to why its stupid.
Trump makes dozens and dozens of such stupid statements on the regular. OEC does not.


