South Carolina executed a guy today with a firing squad

That's critical too, of course. I'm more interested in the technical side of it, as "just shoot better" is kind of hard to solve on a systemic level. The cartridge choice decides everything: you need something with enough blunt force to ensure almost instant unconsciousness from the blow alone, and for that you need a reasonably large cartridge. I suspect the .308 W is underpowered for that, and if Stoic is right, it was.
The .308 Win is in no way, shape, or form underpowered. That cartridge can kill any animal in North America. It wouldn't be my first choice for moose, 400 yd shots on bighorn, or grizzlies, but it can do it. It's a deadly round, and what snipers in the military used for many years. @Stoic1 Sorry to ring your bell again, but what are the preferred rounds for snipers now?
 
The .308 Win is in no way, shape, or form underpowered. That cartridge can kill any animal in North America. It wouldn't be my first choice for moose, 400 yd shots on bighorn, or grizzlies, but it can do it. It's a deadly round, and what snipers in the military used for many years. @Stoic1 Sorry to ring your bell again, but what are the preferred rounds for snipers now?
Underpowered for guaranteeing instant unconsciousness with a torso shot to a human, I mean. It will absolutely kill, but with how much suffering for a human? If Stoic is right that he was awake for the full 15 seconds, that's a lot of pain. It's also possible he went unconscious very rapidly as well, and that the thrashing wasn't done in pain as such. Hard to know.
 
Underpowered for guaranteeing instant unconsciousness with a torso shot to a human, I mean. It will absolutely kill, but with how much suffering for a human? If Stoic is right that he was awake for the full 15 seconds, that's a lot of pain. It's also possible he went unconscious very rapidly as well, and that the thrashing wasn't done in pain as such. Hard to know.
I won't harp on it anymore, but you are just wrong on this. The .308 is more than enough to kill a human instantly, especially at a short distance.

How about this? Why don't we just blow them up? Put a chair in the middle of a field, strap the subject down, and pack the chair with C4? You could set up bleachers and charge admission.
 
I won't harp on it anymore, but you are just wrong on this. The .308 is more than enough to kill a human instantly, especially at a short distance.

How about this? Why don't we just blow them up? Put a chair in the middle of a field, strap the subject down, and pack the chair with C4? You could set up bleachers and charge admission.
Ok, I accept that I'm underestimating the .308 W, or overestimating the human body. Stoic seemed to think the prisoner was in pain for a while, but again, entirely possible that was in an unconscious state, and that there was no pain.
 
I'd have shot him in the dick and said oooops.
You swore an oath to defend the Constitution. I understand the hunger for retribution, but how can you square your oath and wanting to execute someone with cruelty? I am not judging, just want to know your take on this.
 
Ok, I accept that I'm underestimating the .308 W, or overestimating the human body. Stoic seemed to think the prisoner was in pain for a while, but again, entirely possible that was in an unconscious state, and that there was no pain.
My best guess is that it was a poor shot(s). That round would make the heart look like a mound of jelly if the shot was placed right.
 
The .308 Win is in no way, shape, or form underpowered. That cartridge can kill any animal in North America. It wouldn't be my first choice for moose, 400 yd shots on bighorn, or grizzlies, but it can do it. It's a deadly round, and what snipers in the military used for many years. @Stoic1 Sorry to ring your bell again, but what are the preferred rounds for snipers now?

When I was deployed I had the sniper section in my platoon. But it was all urban. One of my guys used an M14 with an EOTECH because every shot was like 200 yards and was just react to contact so F it. That .308 will stop a car faster than any 5.56mm. They had the M10 but we rarely set up to use it except overwatch outer cordon. And NOBODY liked to hump the barrett .50 cal.

.308 is still used in many units. But people don't like it for more than 600-800 y.

But almost every body is transitioning to the MRAD that gives the option of different calibers, .308, 300, and .338.

Personally I think it would have been funny to execute this guy with 3x barret .50cal. Or maybe 30 guys with .22LR.

Honestly, any round that can penetrate the breastplate and expand in the heart should be damn near instant death. A CNS is the only thing that gives near instant kills. That's why I'm surprised this dude lived 15 seconds. But the human body is really weird.
 
Let's hope it wasn't intentionally bad shooting.
That would be heinous. I am guessing it was just incompetence or nerves (which is incompetence). Some people freeze when hunting game. "Buck fever" is what my dad called it. Getting the yips in that situation would be understandable. The shooters should have been military with kills under their belt.
 
I just don't agree here either. Something about using a robot to kill a man seems way more off putting than a human firing squad.

I do think the squad should be volunteers and no one should be forced onto that detail if they don't want it. I almost think friends and family of victim should be allowed onto the squad if they want but i can't figure out a way to ensure they only shoot where they are supposed to. You can't gutshoot the guy or shoot him in the dick. I guess the head is OK since it's also fatal.
Yeah... nut shots all around.
 
I'm torn. I’m not a fan of the government legally murdering people… but I also think some people deserve to die.
<escalate99>


How do you compassionately murder someone? A shot in the back of the head? Lethal injections are not really that great.
 
Last edited:
That .308 will stop a car faster than any 5.56mm.
That much is certain, as the .308 W / 7.62mm NATO is twice as powerful.
But almost every body is transitioning to the MRAD that gives the option of different calibers, .308, 300, and .338.
Do you have any experience with the .338, or general thoughts on it?
 
That would be heinous. I am guessing it was just incompetence or nerves (which is incompetence). Some people freeze when hunting game. "Buck fever" is what my dad called it. Getting the yips in that situation would be understandable. The shooters should have been military with kills under their belt.
You never can tell with this stuff until the moment itself is there. I've never shot to kill anything, so I can't pass personal judgment in that regard. But I've managed to play several concerts with past bands I've been in, so, hey, I'm pretty cool under pressure, right? Whether it's threading a .70 caliber guitar string or shooting a .700 Nitro, the experience passes from on the other other, right?

R-right?
 
Provided someone is 100 percent guilty, yes I know that can be difficult or impossible to determine
in some cases, the conviction to execution process needs to be sped way up.

This guy murdered some people and it took 23 years to carry out the process. Ridiculous.
 
That much is certain, as the .308 W / 7.62mm NATO is twice as powerful.

Do you have any experience with the .338, or general thoughts on it?
My limited experience was with a .338 mag lapua. I'm not sure how different that is from the Norma stuff. After 5 rds with .338 I was done. Recoil felt like 12gauge slugs. Not pleasant.

I don't own a weapon with that caliber. I'm not ready to start stockpiling another caliber. Also, I am not a good long range shooter.
 
You never can tell with this stuff until the moment itself is there. I've never shot to kill anything, so I can't pass personal judgment in that regard. But I've managed to play several concerts with past bands I've been in, so, hey, I'm pretty cool under pressure, right? Whether it's threading a .70 caliber guitar string or shooting a .700 Nitro, the experience passes from on the other other, right?

R-right?
You say it in jest, but walking out in front of a crowd and performing is a test and it will steel your nerves or break you. I've played music in front of people, and it's the same principle. You focus on your part. You let the hours of practice and rehearsal take over. The moment you start thinking about the moment you are fucked. You have one job. Do it.

I'll chime in about the .338 Win. Great round if you are elk, moose, or bear hunting or going to Africa for that matter. I would opt for the 7mm Rem. which is a necked-down .338. Flatter trajectory, better velocity, and more suited for things like whitetail. If I had a 400-500 yd shot, I'd want the 7mm.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,280,309
Messages
58,275,722
Members
175,990
Latest member
gorakk
Back
Top