• Xenforo Cloud is upgrading us to version 2.3.8 on Monday February 16th, 2026 at 12:00 AM PST. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

Remember when Fitch stole a win from BJ Penn!?

To this day it still annoys the fuck out of me, but does anyone remember when Fitch stole a W from BJ Penn?

Fitch tends to be a guy that we as fans kind of sniffle at, due to factors like his wrestling-centric style and the impression that he is "boring". Jon Fitch was a top 5 or 6 Welterweight for almost 10 years, people forget this often.

Penn was a victim of his own bravery throughout his career, taking on all comers and taking L’s to ridiculously large opponents like Machida and even at 170, guys like MacDonald and St. Pierre. People forget how many considerably larger fighters Penn competed against and also how much success he had.

I remember Fitch pretty much laying on Penn for 4 minutes + with the odd elbow thrown in, and the judges gifted him a 10-8 and subsequently - a draw.

I remember looking at the match-up and just being upset, felt similar to Henderson vs Thatch - where you just look at the size difference and you just cannot see him overcoming it.

Penn (in my opinion) technically embarrassed Jon Fitch for the first 10 minutes, and it pisses me off that fights like his now add to the blemishes on an "odd" record of a legend like BJ Penn.

It's more than just W's and L's on a record... Never forget The Prodigy - BJ PENN.

bj-penn1.jpg
Totally disagree. Penn stole a win away from Fitch.
 
Huge Penn fan, but that third round was destruction. Penn was spent and Fitch actually threw gnp for once.

The draw was deserved.
 
I thought Fitch clearly won rds 2 & 3, but whatever. Definitely wasn't mad about it.
 
I had Fitch winning and ending strong. BJ is lucky it wasn' a 5 rounder.
 
It actually should have been a 10-7 round according to the criteria. Fitch would have won with the rule changes no doubt.

Why would you mention the new rules changes? And a good portion of those shots were blocked. I had no problem with the draw.
 
BJ is my favorite fighter of all time but he just gave that one away.
 
Jon won the 2nd and 3rd. 1st was closest and could easily have been a 10-10.

This fight really brought out the delusional Penn fans and I see it hasn't stopped.

3rd was absolutely a 10-8.

BJ was gifted a tie. In reality he lost.
 
Huge Penn fan, but that third round was destruction. Penn was spent and Fitch actually threw gnp for once.

The draw was deserved.

lol yeah right. penn lost that, incompetent judges robbed jon of a win. why wasn't there more outcry? because no one likes fitch.

yet we have babies like TS creating threads thinking that penn won, or that he actually deserved the tie.

it is best for penn fans to just never mention this fight again, because over time more people are going to catch on to how much of a robbery that fight was.
 
NBR conveniently disappeared when I outed him on his alt account that he fucked up on! lol
 
lol yeah right. penn lost that, incompetent judges robbed jon of a win. why wasn't there more outcry? because no one likes fitch.

yet we have babies like TS creating threads thinking that penn won, or that he actually deserved the tie.

it is best for penn fans to just never mention this fight again, because over time more people are going to catch on to how much of a robbery that fight was.

Hi Jon
 
Cannot remember hearing this, but if so - I think he was being a little harsh on himself like always.

BJ won 2 rounds of that fight, 3rd round wasn't this brutal beatdown that people are now pitching it as.

It was a really brutal beat down .
 
@Johnny2fists can you please confirm that I'm not you lol.

Supposedly I'm the owner of your account.

OK but you still haven't explained why you said what you said to me then. You said no one ever said what I said about Penn's losses, even though the guy I quoted in my original post said EXACTLY THAT.

Explain. Not paying attention?
 
OK but you still haven't explained why you said what you said to me then. You said no one ever said what I said about Penn's losses, even though the guy I quoted in my original post said EXACTLY THAT.

Explain. Not paying attention?
Okay, I think I figured this out.

Blame my browser, I think I opened a notification of someone responding to me and I read your comment as if it was geared toward me - that was a mistake on my part.

I then responded to you, and you were then confused at why I was getting involved - you then presumed I had 2 accounts and was responding to you via another account.

Just a mistake, this was funny in retrospect lol.
 
Fitch was the clear #2 ww for a few years. He put on an amazing fight against Erick Silva.
 
Back
Top