Rank these figthers stats.(Max, Volk, Topuria, Poirier and Gaethje)

[PEDRO IVO RUSSO MIRANDA]

With Topuria vs Holloway coming up, I was thinking about some comparisons.

Let me know how you rank Power, Speed, Technique, and fight IQ of these 5 fighters.
Since the comparison is only between these 5, I ask that you give a 10 to the one you consider the best in that area. If there isn't a clear best, give the two best a 9.

Volk.
Speed : 7
Power : 6
Technique : 9
Figth IQ : 10

Justin Gaethje.

Speed : 6
Power : 10
Technique : 6
Figth IQ : 6

Max Holloway.

Speed: 10
Power : 6
Technique : 7
Figth IQ : 7

Ilia Topuria.

Speed : 8
Power : 8
Technique : 7
Figth IQ : 7

Dustin Poirier.

Speed : 8
Power : 7
Technique : 9
Figth IQ: 7

Rate the way you want.
Remember that's just some stats, and the figth itself is far more complicated, but I think that give us some idea to how some figths could go up.

 

[Lord Pyjamas]

Gaethje is no 10 in power!
Without loading up his shots and planting his feet he is just good.

 

[Flower2dPeople]

Volk is just athletic and had a chin on him. I wouldn't rank his fight iq a 10. Ilia was setting him up for a clean shot when they fought.

 

[Hdfi]

Volk.
Speed : 8
Power : 5
Technique : 9
Figth IQ : 10

Justin Gaethje.

Speed : 6
Power : 10
Technique : 7
Figth IQ : 7

Max Holloway.

Speed: 10
Power : 6
Technique : 8
Figth IQ : 8

Ilia Topuria.

Speed : 9
Power : 8
Technique : 7
Figth IQ : 8

Dustin Poirier.

Speed : 8
Power : 7
Technique : 8
Figth IQ: 8

 

[Bret 'The Hitman' Hart]

Chael Sonnen

Speed : 10
Power : 10
Technique : 10
Figth IQ: 11

 

[Hdfi]

Volk is just athletic and had a chin on him. I wouldn't rank his fight iq a 10.

watch his fight vs Yair Rodriguez, that was masterful.

 

[PEDRO IVO RUSSO MIRANDA]

Gaethje is no 10 in power!
Without loading up his shots and planting his feet he is just good.

Butt He's the strongest beetween these 5, thats why i rank him 10.
In the entire rooster hes not 10, for sure

 

[PEDRO IVO RUSSO MIRANDA]

Volk is just athletic and had a chin on him. I wouldn't rank his fight iq a 10. Ilia was setting him up for a clean shot when they fought.

So, beetween these 5, who do you think have the best IQ?

 

[Lord Pyjamas]

Butt He's the strongest beetween these 5, thats why i rank him 10.
In the entire rooster hes not 10, for sure

Ilia Topuria is actually the most efficient power puncher but you are right.
If everything somehow falls into place.
I would not choose Gaethje to punch my face!

 

[blaseblase]

You have only a 1 point different between Poirier and Max in power? That doesn't work. Poirier should be an 8, scale Max down to 5.

 

[Flower2dPeople]

watch his fight vs Yair Rodriguez, that was masterful.

He has the grasp of the fundamentals. A disciplined fighter will almost always beat a Yair type.

 

[Subline]

Say again?

 

[richardjohnson]

Chael Sonnen

Speed : 10
Power : 10
Technique : 10
Figth IQ: 11

Stats almost good enough to make a Sherdog account

 

[arcadeperfect]

Love Max, but why would his speed be a 10? He's not slow, but he's never been portrayed as a speedy fighter like Aldo or Yair. Speed of 6.5 or 7 sounds more reasonable. Dustin having 9 technique is bizarre. How are you basing technique? Or you basing it on the quantity/diversity of the fighter or the aesthetics? In either category Dustin wouldn't be as high as a 9.

 

[PEDRO IVO RUSSO MIRANDA]

Love Max, but why would his speed be a 10? He's not slow, but he's never been portrayed as a speedy fighter like Aldo or Yair. Speed of 6.5 or 7 sounds more reasonable. Dustin having 9 technique is bizarre. How are you basing technique? Or you basing it on the quantity/diversity of the fighter or the aesthetics? In either category Dustin wouldn't be as high as a 9.

Since the sample is only these 5 fighters, I established that the best in each area should be rated as 10.

I think most people didn't read the rating conditions, but that's okay.
Or do you think any of these 5 is faster than Max?

I'm giving a 9 whenever there isn't a clear best among the 5, and tying the 2 that I think are the best. In this case, I rated Poirier's and Volk's technique as 9.

 

[arcadeperfect]

Since the sample is only these 5 fighters, I established that the best in each area should be rated as 10.

I think most people didn't read the rating conditions, but that's okay.
Or do you think any of these 5 is faster than Max?

I'm giving a 9 whenever there isn't a clear best among the 5, and tying the 2 that I think are the best. In this case, I rated Poirier's and Volk's technique as 9.

My mistake, if it's relative to each other then that makes more sense. Volk being only a 7 in speed is low. Volk never looked drastically slower than Max, infact he's probably the faster of the 2. Volk's technique is better than Poirier's, he gets hit far less and looks much cleaner.

 

[Harlekin]

You guys got Topuria's technique way too low.
He overthrows punches to get knockouts, ok I get it.
Does this still way more technical than Gaethje.
Other then that he is top notch all around

 

[DanDragon Machi]

Volk.
Speed : 8
Power : 7
Technique : 9
Figth IQ : 10

Gaethje.
Speed : 7
Power : 9
Technique : 6
Figth IQ : 6

Holloway.
Speed: 7
Power : 6
Technique : 9
Figth IQ : 8

Topuria.
Speed : 7
Power : 8
Technique : 9
Figth IQ : 8

Poirier.
Speed : 7
Power : 8
Technique : 8
Figth IQ: 8