Seth over Balor for my vote: peak Rollins superior to peak Balor, Rollins is way better on the mic and show more personality throughout his WWE run. However, an Balor heel run hasn't occurred yet but heel Rollins was great in spite of his world title reign been Honky Tonk Man 2.0.
Balor had that match with AJ Styles at TLC, but outside of that nothing memorable on the main roster just smiling face with a jacket. Zero character outsid of that and the Demon rarely shows up so that's a non-factor for me. Wearing paint doesn't increase your personality/character at all if there's no depth.
Rollins had the 2014 series with Ambrose, that gauntlet match, tag series against the Bar, IC title matches againist Miz/Ziggler.
Balor had that match with AJ Styles at TLC, but outside of that nothing memorable on the main roster just smiling face with a jacket. Zero character outsid of that and the Demon rarely shows up so that's a non-factor for me. Wearing paint doesn't increase your personality/character at all if there's no depth.
Rollins had the 2014 series with Ambrose, that gauntlet match, tag series against the Bar, IC title matches againist Miz/Ziggler.