- Joined
- Apr 8, 2009
- Messages
- 15,112
- Reaction score
- 0
Here is something I wrote elsewhere, relevant to betting on individual states. Guy was arguing that NM is less likely to go Trump than PA based on what experts said. I disagreed:
Most of the "experts" are no better than the polls they are looking at. If you are aware of a demographic/regional breakdown of voting patterns in these states which can tell us more than the raw polling, do share.
My point on third-party support is that it's easier to turn a Johnson voter into a Trump voter than it is to turn a Clinton voter into a Trump voter. So states like NM with lots of Johnson support might be more likely to go Trump than a state like PA with more polarization, even if Clinton is +8 in both.
Johnson is only polling at 6 in PA while he is polling at 16 in NM. Both states are showing about 10% undecided. Now, I happen to think undecideds are going to favor Trump big over Clinton, but still not enough to erase an 8% gap. Thus For Trump to win PA or NM he needs to either a) convert Clinton voters (unlikely) b) convert Johnson supporters (much more likely). This task is easier in a state like NM with lots of Johnson support than in a state like PA with little Johnson support.
Most of the "experts" are no better than the polls they are looking at. If you are aware of a demographic/regional breakdown of voting patterns in these states which can tell us more than the raw polling, do share.
My point on third-party support is that it's easier to turn a Johnson voter into a Trump voter than it is to turn a Clinton voter into a Trump voter. So states like NM with lots of Johnson support might be more likely to go Trump than a state like PA with more polarization, even if Clinton is +8 in both.
Johnson is only polling at 6 in PA while he is polling at 16 in NM. Both states are showing about 10% undecided. Now, I happen to think undecideds are going to favor Trump big over Clinton, but still not enough to erase an 8% gap. Thus For Trump to win PA or NM he needs to either a) convert Clinton voters (unlikely) b) convert Johnson supporters (much more likely). This task is easier in a state like NM with lots of Johnson support than in a state like PA with little Johnson support.