Pac won the fight by SD IMO, didn't JMM also hold on to the ropes with 7 seconds in the RD he got KD in??? Lampley mentioned that should of been a KD as well. Marquez did a great job of slowing down the fight and countering beautifully, but he doesn't have enough pop to slow down Pacman, Pac kept pushing the action and was landing the harder punches, Marquez was hurt several times after the KD.
I agree from RDs 5-8 JMM dominated with countering, but Pac would land 1 or 2 punches at a time that would hurt Marquez. You can see Marquez hesistate a lot from RD 9 on because he had to respect Pac's power, he couldn't be anymore agressive because he doesn't have the power to match pac in a slugfest. He didn't box enough is my point, when he decided to throw it cost him IMO!
You're giving 5,6,7,8 to JMM. Most people agree JMM won 1,2 as well and clearly won 12 no doubt about that. That 7-5 JMM which would give him the edge. I had it 8-4 for Marquez but no way manny won 6 rounds.