Having had time for it to settle, I find the new ratings system crap. Bad aesthetic aside, it has no meaning.
Last night I looked up some 15 games to test and see: 4.43, 4.16, 4.71, 4.02, 4.36... out of 5 stars. Virtually every game in-store falls on this 4 spectrum and it offers no value to me as a peruser anyway. Lowest game I've seen is 3.91 and that was widely mocked UFC 5 from E(at)A(ss). From a UX standpoint, taking rating values to the hundredths is also cognitive overload.
Roll back the new ratings system from game product pages, IMO. Don't need it. Don't want it.
Anyone like it? Let me hear thoughts.