Most Meaningless Victories in the UFC?

[DestinedAussie]

Not counting DQ victories. I'm thinking Ryan Hall heel hooking a broken BJ Penn. Any other candidates?

Khabib fighting raging Al for belt when he wasn't a contender and was like 4th in line of last minute replacements.

 

[JonJonesNeedle]

DC vs. Patrick Cummins

It only served as a tune-up for DC's 205 debut, but Cummins should have never fought DC in the first place. Their feud was over the dumbest shit

What was the feud over? They had some beef back in college wrestling days or something right?

 

[2004 account]

Randy beating James toney

Any of the 12 victories Tony ferg got before not winning the real belt

Cro cop beating Eddie Sanchez

Any victory over cm punk

 

[Mangar]

 

[Frank Edgar]

What was the feud over? They had some beef back in college wrestling days or something right?

It was some really dumb shit like that, yes. I think Cummins had beat DC in wrestling or something

You could tell it was totally fabricated to hype up a shitty short notice fight (it was the co main event, Cummins replaced Rashad) and make it seem like it had actual stakes

 

[cheesus]

Stipe over Maldonado

 

[DesiredUserName]

Randy Couture and James Toney...

 

[kuroro]

I TOLD YOU NOT COUNTING DQ

 

[Cowboy Kurt Angle]

Matt Hughes over Royce Gracie

 

[Professional]

Leonard Garcia....close your eyes and throw a dart at his resume. It will land on a meaningless UD that he didn't deserve.

 

[Jfreemandrums]

Any win that is WMAA.
And before the white knights even start typing with their mask on, I feel women should be able to compete at any sport they choose.
I'm all for women's (equal not exalted) rights.
But other than Nunez, Shevchinko, Rose and a very select few others I wanna see WMMA as much as I wanna see a man breast feed.

Is your username some kind of homage to Mike Perry?

 

[SherdogFan23]

A win by any fighter who is in or near their prime over a fighter that is past their prime is always over-rated. It gets used on arguments on most threads in this forum to attempt to make points.

 

[DestinedAussie]

Randy beating James toney

Any of the 12 victories Tony ferg got before not winning the real belt

Cro cop beating Eddie Sanchez

Any victory over cm punk

What about CM Punks no contest. Like the fight never happened.

 

[lostdog000]

most cyborg fights, theyd find some washed up 125 pound chick to fight her at 145

 

[BowserJr]

Salmon vs Rashad

 

[BowserJr]

Chuck vs Horn

In the old days they would give guys cans
Diego Sanchez vs Brian Gassaway
Josh Koscheck vs Jeff Joslin
Stephan Bonnar vs Mike Nickels
Forrest Griffin vs Hector Ramirez
Shane Carwin vs Neil Wain
JDS vs Gilbert Yvel

Jeff Joslin was solid. He got robbed against Fitch who was on his streak and perennial #2

 

[Draxton]

Randy vs James Toney

 

[Alexander_GOATanovski]

Randy Couture and James Toney...

It took 7 pages before someone actually gave the correct answer. Ignoring DQ wins & blatant robberies, beating a boxer with NO MMA training is as meaningless as it gets in the UFC. Every other answer (esp. the McGregor ones) is driven by emotional ppl who mostly hate seeing their most hated fighter win or hate seeing their favorite fighter lose.

Any of the 12 victories Tony ferg got before not winning the real belt

Worst comment in the entire thread... remove the bitterness from your heart. El Cucuy bless your bum soul.

 

[DLX]

Edwards beating Khamzat. Good thing he's not taking that fight.

 

[HHJ]

I dont like these kinds of threads. Just demeaning things people strove and fought for. Suckin the fun right out of it.

It is not Ryan Hall's fault BJ wasnt good anymore. Why try to take that away from him any further?