Law Man who came to the US lawfully at 9mo Exonerated after 43 years in Prison - Immediately Arrested by ICE and Awaiting Deportation

650lb Sumo

Breakout Poster of the Year 2025 🏆
@Silver
Joined
Aug 25, 2021
Messages
13,807
Reaction score
33,790

2000.jpg


A Pennsylvania man who was recently exonerated after spending more than four decades behind bars has now been taken into custody by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and faces possible deportation to India.

Earlier this month Centre County’s District Attorney dismissed murder charges against 64-year-old Subramanyam 'Subu' Vedam. However shortly after his exoneration Vedam was detained by ICE based on a 1988 deportation order tied to his now-vacated convictions.

More than 40 years ago Vedam was convicted of the murder of Tom Kinser, a 19-year-old student who went missing from State College in 1980. Kinser’s body was discovered nine months later in a wooded area with a bullet wound in his skull.

gettyimages-2224603707-20250718203152525.jpg

Immigration and Customs Enforcement

Kinser and Vedam were former classmates and had lived together briefly as housemates. On the day Kinser disappeared Vedam asked for a ride. Kinser’s car was later found parked in its usual spot, though no one saw it being returned. Vedam, who was born in India and arrived in the US at nine months old, was charged with Kinser’s murder and had his passport and green card seized by authorities. He was also denied bail, as he was labelled a 'foreigner likely to flee'.

In 1983 Vedam was convicted of murder and sentenced to life in prison. A year later he received an additional sentence of two-and-a-half to five years for a drug offence, as part of a plea deal that was to be served simultaneously with his life sentence.

While in prison Vedam maintained his innocence of the murder charges and continued to appeal against his conviction on circumstantial evidence. In 2021 new evidence in Kinser’s murder case surfaced, leading to Vedam’s exoneration earlier this month. The Centre County District Attorney also announced it will not seek a new trial against Vedam.

However, upon his exoneration Vedam was taken into custody by ICE. In a statement to the Miami Herald the agency accused Vedam of being a 'a career criminal with a rap sheet dating back to 1980', adding that he is 'also a convicted controlled substance trafficker'.

Speaking to USA Today, Vedam’s lawyer Ava Benach

BC-Website-43-scaled.webp


said: “Subu has lived in the US since he was a nine-month-old infant when he and his family arrived as lawful permanent residents of the United States … He was still a lawful permanent resident, and his application for citizenship had been accepted, when he was arrested in 1982.”

Highlighting Vedam as Pennsylvania’s longest-incarcerated prisoner to be exonerated, Benach emphasised that Vedam 'forfeited four decades of his life to a prison sentence for a murder he didn’t commit', and should therefore be given the opportunity to rebuild his life in the US, USA Today reported.

Vedam’s niece, Zoë Miller-Vedam

zoe1-03-cropped.jpg


echoed similar sentiments to the outlet, saying: “All we want is for him to be home with us and to be able to move forward in life.”

Vedam is being held at the Moshannon Valley Processing Centre,

20252905TRMOSHANNON-14_1759352377.jpg


an immigration detention facility in Philipsburg, Pennsylvania, as his family awaits an update on his deportation case.

A motion to reopen Vedam's immigration case was filed 3rd October, the day ICE arrested him, and is now before the Board of Immigration Appeals, family spokesman Mike Truppa said.
 
So the drug charges he was guilty of right.

So why were the charges overturned? Nothing i can find in the article says.
 
Last edited:
A green card holder, with prior drug charges. The judge through out the case because certain evidence wasn't allowed during the hearing. He is a green card holder and subject to deportation. But for the amount of time he spent in jail, especially if he had a unfair trial, I think they could make an exception give him a new green card.
 
So why were the charges overturned? Nothing i can find in the article says thst.

There was a FBI report proving that the gun Vedam had access to was not the gun used in the crime.
The deformed bullet found in the victim was simply too small to have been fired from the gun he had access to.
This undermined the whole case the prosecutor put forward.
But the prosecutor did not disclosed this evidence to the defense, it was concealed
It was found 2022 by Vedems attorney in archives of the Centre County District Attorney’s Office.

Testimonies from todays leading forensic experts earlier this year, supported the old FBI report.

 
Last edited:
And now imagine you're the ICE agents licking your chops waiting for his release from a 40 year wrongful imprisonment so you can deport him
You think everyone with ICE badge is some lunatic that loves to capture people ? They’re human beings behind the uniforms. That bleeding compassion you have for illegals, have some for those people that serve in those roles . They are demonized for following orders and the new boogie man
 
He's not a US citizen, correct?
 
If you had read the OP, you would have seen the part that says
nS1vYjW.png
That doesn't answer my question. The OP says he had a green card and had "applied for citizenship at the time of his arrest" . Green cards expire, even those designated "permanent".
 
That doesn't answer my question. The OP says he had a green card and had "applied for citizenship at the time of his arrest" . Green cards expire, even those designated "permanent".
He is not a US citizen. You can't (lawfully) be deported from a country you are a citizen of.

Sometimes it happens in error or I suppose sometimes maliciously.

You could have your citizenship revoked and then be deported but that is not what is happening in this case.
 
You think everyone with ICE badge is some lunatic that loves to capture people ? They’re human beings behind the uniforms. That bleeding compassion you have for illegals, have some for those people that serve in those roles . They are demonized for following orders and the new boogie man

You're in a thread rationalizing the deportation of someone who had been wrongly imprisoned for four decades. I say deport him, but let him sue and win a hundred million for the four decades America stole from him, and let him take it to a civilized country.

Fuck ICE, too. The bullshit propaganda from the right in service of enabling them to act as a heavily armed group that operates incognito is antithetical to democracy. The insanely skewed math they used to illustrate the increase in assaults proved how they know the right won't look closely at the numbers.

Just so you know (not that you'll care), the numbers are a raw percentage that ignores the increase in the size of ICE (it isn't a per capita percentage), the increase in ICE activity, the aggression ICE has been showing, and the lowered standard for "assault".
 
Man imagine going to a new country and getting wrongfully convicted for decades. If I was him I would be running to anywhere besides America.
 
Back
Top