In that deadlift video and your squat videos I noticed that you appear to have some lumbar rounding, which almost everyone says not to do, but it's obviously working for you since you're strong and healthy, and I see a lot of other
really strong guys who seem to round consistently and remain injury-free. What factors do you think should be taken into consideration as to when someone is "allowed" to round?
Also, really fantastic lifting there.
Yeah, most everyone is in agreement on the subject of lumbar rounding being a bad thing, but there are degrees of rounding. This seems to be less about the extent to which the lumbar rounds, and more about the extent to which the lumbar is "loaded" (or forced to strain under a compromised position) during the lift. Your question is a really difficult one to answer, and the answer I've given to questions like this up until this point is: a lifter should always try to learn to squat and deadlift with a neutral spine. If--and when--rounding occurs, a lifter will find out if he or she can handle rounding simply by either getting hurt or not getting hurt.
That is pretty awful advice, but it's the best I can give. The guys who lift with a rounded back are the ones who have been doing it, injury-free, for years. I've never had an issue with my lower back--in fact, I've never had any sort of back injury.
As an anecdote to this, the Outlaw forum was recently talking about Steve Goggins, a legendary multi-ply powerlifter who has pulled 900 in the gym and just squatted 802 raw at 49 years of age. People were saying that Goggins has never gotten hurt, besides one muscle pull; no tears, no breaks, no nothing. If you've watched him lift, you'll see that everything he does is with a very horizontal torso position--he is probably the most "back-heavy" equipped squatter in history. And yet despite this, he's never gotten hurt.
Either he's really lucky, or he trained his back to absorb that stress...or both.
I didn't catch the 480X10... That's some serious shit right there...
Also what did the good doc say? Or would you just be scheduling an appointment at this point?
No appointment yet! I'm giving the fiber-heavy diet a week to get some results. So far, my body's been pretty regular and I haven't gotten sick. So far, so good.
I would also like to hear Keo's response to this, but since I just read the following article yesterday, here is a link:
http://www.danogborn.com/training/deadlifts-rounded-backs-weak-hips/
Here is an excerpt from the article:
Despite striving for a neutral or arched spine during the deadlift, research from Stuart McGill has found that when individual lumbar vertebrae of powerlifters are observed (with a very fancy camera), a certain degree of lumbar flexion occurs (1). Perhaps most important, the experienced lifters used in this particular study were able to control the degree of flexion such that the terminal ends of the flexion range of motion were never achieved. This suggests that lumbar flexion can and does occur in the deadlift, but experienced lifters have a degree a kinaesthetic awareness that allows them to avoid end-range of motion in order to prevent injury.
Very interesting excerpt--I'll read the rest when I get home. I agree with everything here; whenever I hear someone say that my lumbar is rounding on my lifts, I tell them that while this is true, I'm not really "loading" the lumbar but, rather, the spinal erectors. In other words, I'm lifting oftentimes with a rounded lumbar back, but that's not where the brunt of the force is being absorbed. So yes, I agree with this. Unfortunately, I don't have any answers for how a lifter becomes experienced in rounded-back lifting. The simple answer is to try for a neutral spine but allow for some occasional technical breakdown, and if you survive it injury-free for long enough, you've probably figured something out.