I think people over analyze too much. The second fight will tell us everything we need to know. As far as the first fight goes....I stand by my first thought. It was flukish in the sense that Anderson lost it rather than Weidman doing anything great to win. If he wins second fight then fair enough he's the better fighter.
I have to say that if you actually think that then you missed a lot of the smaller things in the fight. In particular the small adjustments Weidman made that allowed him to land his shots while making Anderson miss and the way Weidman avoiding getting baited by Anderson.
Those little things make all the difference as it was Chris' actions that prevented him getting highlighted as everyone thought he was about to be.
Here is my explanation and what you missed from another thread.
------------------------------
His actions were specifically different than anything we've seen and exceptional.
Anderson has made a career out of baiting guys into his game. He drops his hands and challenges their pride and they become completely ineffectual and run at him, giving him exactly what he wants. Or they get frustrated and quit mentally.
Weidman remained focused in the face of taunting and did not bite and run at Anderson and instead kept to his game plan of picking HIS SPOTS instead of chasing Anderson's bait and openings. He continued to measure Anderson and to bait him back which no one has ever done.
That was step one of Anderson's demise.
Weidman then went a step further as his confidence grew and he began to taunt Silva by dropping his hands and offering up his head for free punches like Nick Diaz taunts his opponents. This threw Anderson as no one had done that to him before and it made Anderson miss in his attempts to him.
that was step two of Anderson's demise.
Which lead to this statement by Anderson after the fight.
"After he lost, though, (Anderson) admitted that he struggled, and that he couldn't hit Weidman."
And Weidman was landing shots all through the fight even as Anderson missed above and was pretending Weidman was not hitting and upping his clowing.
Anderson getting tagged and realizing he was struggling to hit a hands down taunting Chris was step 3 of his demise.
When a guy feigns a strike did not hurt you often know it did. Especially when you can see it from another angle and closer...
the big shots landed were the finale.
enter KTFO gif which ends the fight.
So yes, Weidman did's lots special and unique as no one had done those things to Anderson in his UFC run. No one had come close.
And Chris deserves full credit as he beat Anderson with his actions and by dictating the fight and forcing Anderson's hand. Anderson did not beat himself.