As a massive JDS fan, this is the most annoying popular opinion. So many people regurgitate this line and have zero idea what they're taking about. They see clips of the fights and the aftermath then look at his record and immediately assume JDS fell off. This is extremely disrespectful and dead wrong.
Tony Ferguson accumulated damage for over a decade before the war with Justin, which was the final straw. Chuck was an iron chinned monster spanning entire eras before the accumulated damage from multiple wars finally caught up with him. JDS isn't some fragile little boy who had a accident and can't play ball anymore.
He was relatively unscathed before the Cain wars and you think he could go from fresh fighter to past his prime just like that? How weak do you think he is?
Good thing we can easily see that this belief is completely wrong. Immediately after the second Cain fight he went to war with Stipe and his cardio, his speed, his power, his durability...
he looked truly amazing there against a very dangerous opponent.
As for his record, Junior is a dynamic, heavy handed fencing type boxer with great grappling and takedown defense. Before the Cain trilogy his best opponents were
- old Cro Cop
- still green in striking Werdum
- powerful but slow Roy Nelson
- Gonzaga
- the always dangerous Shane Carwin
- BJJ specialist Frank Mir
Not saying they're not good wins. Werdum and Mir were dangerous but JDS's elite grappling defense was good enough to keep it on the feet. They are all good wins and dangerous men but JDS is JDS; he was just better than them or his abilities countered their styles.
After Cain, who did he lose to?
- Alistair Overeem
- Champion Stipe Miocic
These days it's clear he's a shadow of the man he used to be, but his decline did NOT start immediately after Cain had his hand raised in their third fight. What's more, although JDS is far weaker now than he used to be he's still a top 15 UFC HW who only lost to the best. Even now he has a chance of becoming champion in any organization outside the UFC. Unless of course, the four straight losses deteriorated his chin too much but we don't know that.
- ONE: Arjan Bhullar. JDS destroys him.
- Bellator: Valentin Moldavski: great fight but IMO JDS is better on the feet and Moldavski wouldn't be able to get it to the ground
- PFL: Philipe Lins won one. If JDS enters, he'd be a huge favorite.