• Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.

If Leon Edwards beats Belal Muhammad in decisive fashion, does he move up on the P4P rankings?

If Leon Edwards beats Belal Muhammad in decisive fashion, does he move up on the P4P rankings?


  • Total voters
    45

Takes Two To Tango

The one who doesn't fall, doesn't stand up.
Platinum Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
36,177
Reaction score
49,121
Leon currently 4th in the P4P rankings.

The top 3 are:

1. Islam
2. Poatan
3. Jon Jones

MV5BOTQyNmQ0ZjQtZmZiNS00Zjg1LWJlMTUtYzUyZWY2ZThmMThmXkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyMTk4MDgwNA@@._V1_FMjpg_UX1000_.jpg
 
Probably won't. It'll be the winningest challenger in his division, so it should amount to something, but it'll be his first defense over an actual challenger too.

People hang on too much to the legacy of Jones rather than the recency that a current ranking system should have. Poatan and Islam seemed to bypass Jones only because of beating champs from multiple divisions
 
No probably not, but he should already be higher than he is.

Islam got his #1 spot by beating the P4P #1 in Volk.

But the only reason Volk was in that spot was because Leon KOed the previous #1 in Usman.

Leon beats the top guy and gets 4th. Islam then beats the new top guy and replaces him at the top.
 
Somewhat expecting him to ko' that guy.
<FookIsThatGuy>

Definitely not in a p4p conversation.

Drop that shit.
 
No probably not, but he should already be higher than he is.

Islam got his #1 spot by beating the P4P #1 in Volk.

But the only reason Volk was in that spot was because Leon KOed the previous #1 in Usman.

Leon beats the top guy and gets 4th. Islam then beats the new top guy and replaces him at the top.
Im conviced that if you're managed by Ali you'll have a better chance of being p4p no 1.

Just think about it, how the hell was usman ever number 1???

Volk beat max 3 times and aldo as well.

Izzy beat Whittaker twice, finished him once, and also turned in wins over Yoel and Gastelum.


These accomplishments FAR outweigh anything Usman has accomplished. should have never been number 1. Just like Islam shouldn't be.
 
Leon's previously somewhat contentious relationship with the UFC is going to be an obstacle regarding promotion unless he begins starching people early and often.

That said, I've never heard of his opponent; so I doubt any sort of win over him will move the needle much as far as management is concerned.
 
Probably won't. It'll be the winningest challenger in his division, so it should amount to something, but it'll be his first defense over an actual challenger too.

People hang on too much to the legacy of Jones rather than the recency that a current ranking system should have. Poatan and Islam seemed to bypass Jones only because of beating champs from multiple divisions
Fair points!

Do you believe that this'd be the case if his bout with Gane had been anything in the realm of competitive?
 
Fair points!

Do you believe that this'd be the case if his bout with Gane had been anything in the realm of competitive?
Maybe, but their P4P rankings have always had this bias of 'the win is the win and that's it,' and champs automatically get vaulted to the top on bonus points, even usually over the best non-champ in a better division. So even with a competitive bout, they'd be (excuse the pun) championing his 2nd divisional title regardless, and add it to the legacy of his first. On paper, it's pretty hard to beat, if a bit pick-and-choosy with their logic.

"Here's a very recent accomplishment without a lot of depth and substance, and if we just combine it with this pretty old thing filled with depth and substance, then all things are even!"
 
Maybe, but their P4P rankings have always had this bias of 'the win is the win and that's it,' and champs automatically get vaulted to the top on bonus points, even usually over the best non-champ in a better division. So even with a competitive bout, they'd be (excuse the pun) championing his 2nd divisional title regardless, and add it to the legacy of his first. On paper, it's pretty hard to beat, if a bit pick-and-choosy with their logic.

"Here's a very recent accomplishment without a lot of depth and substance, and if we just combine it with this pretty old thing filled with depth and substance, then all things are even!"

Can't argue with that
 
Back
Top