Greatest of All Time update

[eatthisjerry]

Georges St-Pierre

P4P wins: Fitch, Penn x2, Hughes x2, Sherk, Shields, Condit, Alves

Most top 5 & top 10 wins

Most well rounded fighter

Has ruled the toughest division for many years

Avenged all loses

Over half of his fights have been world title fights

Holds the many records in the UFC (fight metric)

First and only winner of UFC champion vs UFC champion fight

Beaten other (arguably) top 10/5 of all timers (Hughes and Penn)

Best wrestler of all time MMA




Where you at haters!

Spoiler

Finishing is not an argument towards skill

Sorry, I fell asleep while reading...

 

[Momanjabo]

I'm not voting.

Fedor, Anderson Silva and GSP.

 

[KJE416]

It has to be fedor. A man with no weakness and a man who could get in the cage with anyone. It cant be said about any other fighter yet. Which makes him the pfp GOAT

 

[Randy Marsh]

If you're going to even put Fedor on the list, you should call the poll "emotional fan favorite of all time"

Because he belongs nowhere in the same convo as GSP, Anderson

GSP disagrees with this post. (as do the majority of all pro MMA fighters)

http://www.mmafighting.com/2008/09/19/georges-st-pierre-fedor-emelianenko-is-mmas-best-pound-for-po

 

[Kalmah]

Based Fyodor

 

[Shonuff1980**]

If you're going to even put Fedor on the list, you should call the poll "emotional fan favorite of all time"

Because he belongs nowhere in the same convo as GSP, Anderson

 

[Deleted member 245586]

How do you decide today who the greatest of all times is when 4 of the guys in the poll are still writing their stories?

 

[Gun'n'Run]

This x 100. He is levels above those guys.

See, this is what I meant. No way in hell is that a real opinion, based on an open-minded evaluation. It's just Fedor love, all over your face, down your chin.

Not only is Anderson a better fighter but he'd destroy Fedor if they fought in their primes, despite any size difference.

 

[bub**]

Jones.

 

[toddy]

Dan Henderson? Dafuq?

LOL SERIOUSLY

You list Hendo as an option and ignore Aldo :icon_neut:icon_neut:icon_neut

 

[Uncommon Valor]

Hendo?

And I guess there really is no "greatest."

 

[MiroHa]

See, this is what I meant. No way in hell is that a real opinion, based on an open-minded evaluation. It's just Fedor love, all over your face, down your chin.

Not only is Anderson a better fighter but he'd destroy Fedor if they fought in their primes, despite any size difference.

I don't really see how he could do that. Fedor outstruck Cro Cop and smashed through Nogueira's guard so I don't see Anderson beating Fedor in those areas.

 

[FedorandBjpenn]

Its Fedor. I would pretty much take a prime fedor over ANY FIGHTER EVER

 

[TheComebackKid]

Silva easy. Fedor fans are living in the past

 

[MiroHa]

LOL SERIOUSLY

You list Hendo as an option and ignore Aldo :icon_neut:icon_neut:icon_neut

I don't think Aldo is quite in the top 5 on the GOAT list.

 

[fanmma]

Fedor.

 

[ShagginTurtles]

IMO

Silva is a 10 standing but like a 7 for grappling and wrestling [17]

Fedor is like an 8 for standing and a 9 for grappling and wrestling [17]

GSP is a 9 for standing and a 10 for grappling and wrestling [19]

 

[SKN TTK]

Silva easy. Fedor fans are living in the past

Oh? The past doesn't fall under the "All Time" classification?

 

[rearnakedchoke]

not a real poll without ruben villareal or jay ellis ...

1. Anderson
2. GSP
3. Fedor

 

[MiroHa]

Silva easy. Fedor fans are living in the past

I think this is a pretty good time for a poll since Anderson isn't backed up with UFC's GOAT hype as much as he was before Weidman KO'd him.