Greatest of All Time update

[Hans Gercmiov]

Anderson.

Dan Henderson?

 

[Mikeyz]

It's been a while since we had a GOAT poll, and I am curious to see how recent events, such as Silva's loss and Jones' war with Gustafsson affect Sherdog's opinion.

Vote away!

Fedor

 

[ajmonsta]

Number 1-schaub
Number 2-fedor

 

[Deleted member 428241]

Other - Rickson

He only fought cans except of Nakai and Funaki.
Nowhere near GOAT-Status.

 

[ajmonsta]

He only fought cans except of Nakai and Funaki.
Nowhere near GOAT-Status.

But he's like 400-0

 

[eatthisjerry]

Number 1-schaub
Number 2-fedor

Wrong.
It's a MMA ranking, not a BJJ poll.

 

[jmadtx]

fedor of course

 

[Winston Wolf]

It's Emelianenko

I picked Anderson but my opinion is that they're both tied at the very top, and no way wan can surpass the other.

 

[StupidityKills]

all day

Bitches don't lie.

 

[Deleted member 428241]

But he's like 400-0

 

[Gun'n'Run]

If you're going to even put Fedor on the list, you should call the poll "emotional fan favorite of all time"

Because he belongs nowhere in the same convo as GSP, Anderson

 

[Lead]

I see no point in comparing different weight classes. I picked Dan just because I think he's accomplished more in 3 different classes than anyone else.

 

[Therealseagal]

Inb4 giant 100 page argument and discrediting. And gun and run just kicked it off.

 

[ShagginTurtles]

Georges St-Pierre

P4P wins: Fitch, Penn x2, Hughes x2, Sherk, Shields, Condit, Alves

Most top 5 & top 10 wins

Most well rounded fighter

Has ruled the toughest division for many years

Avenged all loses

Over half of his fights have been world title fights

Holds the many records in the UFC (fight metric)

First and only winner of UFC champion vs UFC champion fight

Beaten other (arguably) top 10/5 of all timers (Hughes and Penn)

Best wrestler of all time MMA




Where you at haters!

Spoiler

Finishing is not an argument towards skill

 

[Degen Gambler]

70% Jones smashes all these dudes.

 

[Lead]

If you're going to even put Fedor on the list, you should call the poll "emotional fan favorite of all time"

Because he belongs nowhere in the same convo as GSP, Anderson

Lets all pretend Tanner belongs in the MMA HOF too.

 

[Sivo The Ram]

1. fedor
2. gsp
3. jon
4. anderson
5. ? idk, big nog? hendo?

 

[Jason AG]

The emperor

 

[eXtv]

Nog deserves to be at least an honorable mention. The guy's longevity and resume is goddamn insane.

 

[Hanri]

Because he belongs nowhere in the same convo as GSP, Anderson

This x 100. He is levels above those guys.