Greatest of All Time update

[MANIAC123]

GSP is the current GOAT in my opinion. Jones one day could surpass him.

 

[Post Crisis]

Gotta go with Fedor. A streak like that at HW will not be matched.

 

[Corleone187]

looks like a landslide for Fedor

 

[Po]

I loved Fedor's style and humbleness but you people need to watch the Arona fight.
Jon Jones is probably the goat.

 

[Mr. Fresca]

lol @ Henderson

 

[ericscarface]

how the fuck is jon jones on the list??

 

[Brick Plenary]

lol @ Henderson

Hendo is one of the greats, no doubt. I can see how it's questioned though. Still a great IMO.

And in even more honesty, I believe Jake Shields belongs on the consideration list.
Shields has one of the best resumes in all of MMA. Being boring doesn't mean you're not great. Lots of casuals are blinded by flashiness.

 

[EliteLurker]

I think it's GSP based on wins. But I always say that Fedor has the best streak, GSP beat the best guy, and Silva did the most impressive things.

Honestly, Jones, Aldo, and even Barao all are amazing and Weidman is starting his run with both feet running. I think many of the old guard will be surpasses sooner rather than later.

 

[Toothless King]

Dan Henderson? Dafuq?

-Olympian in Greco wrestling
-He was the only mixed martial artist to concurrently hold two titles in two different weight classes in a major MMA promotion. Henderson is also the UFC 17 Middleweight Tournament Winner, the 1997 Brazil Open Lightweight Tournament Champion, the RINGS King of Kings 1999 Tournament Winner, and the 2005 PRIDE Welterweight Grand Prix Champion. As of August 2013, Henderson is ranked the #5 light heavyweight by Sherdog.[4]
-43 years old and still competitve

 

[GGpX]

Right now,

1) Anderson
2) Fedor
3) GSP

imo.

 

[Kylewood95]

Seeing Fedor with the most votes has made me lose faith in Sherdog

 

[Brick Plenary]

Seeing Fedor with the most votes has made me lose faith in Sherdog

Says the kid born in 1995.

 

[Kylewood95]

Says the kid born in 1995.

lol I've seen almost all of Fedors fights, yes he is one of the best but is most certainly not the best

 

[Elmonstro1]

Seeing Fedor with the most votes has made me lose faith in Sherdog

Lol thats all it takes? Loser

 

[Mr. Fresca]

-Olympian in Greco wrestling
-He was the only mixed martial artist to concurrently hold two titles in two different weight classes in a major MMA promotion. Henderson is also the UFC 17 Middleweight Tournament Winner, the 1997 Brazil Open Lightweight Tournament Champion, the RINGS King of Kings 1999 Tournament Winner, and the 2005 PRIDE Welterweight Grand Prix Champion. As of August 2013, Henderson is ranked the #5 light heavyweight by Sherdog.[4]
-43 years old and still competitve

The problem is that he has too many losses to be in GOAT discussion.

Hendo has an incredible resume no doubt, but too many losses. It's like when people talk about Couture being a GOAT.

 

[Kylewood95]

Lol thats all it takes? Loser

no I had already lost most of my faith in sherdog after reading through the forums, but this is probably the last straw

 

[Hanri]

lol I've seen almost all of Fedors fights, yes he is one of the best but is most certainly not the best

Expert has spoken. Can we already remover Fedor from the poll?

/thread

 

[KAZSoliloquy]

Clearly it's Emmanuel Yarborough.

Voted Other.

 

[Kirin]

I love seeing all the love for Фёдор.

 

[GearSolidMetal]

Answer before Silva/Weidman1 - Fedor

Answer after Silva/Weidman1 - Fedor

Answer after Silva/Weidman2 - Fedor