There are conflicting versions of this. Conor stated he already had it wrapped up before the Siver fight, giving us this famous quote: "I would like Cub to win for the specific reason that he seems to think he has been promised the UFC title shot if he wins this fight against Frankie, so I want to him to win that contest, and then I will bake a freshly made pie and smack him clean in the face with it when I get the title shot.” In his view, he earned the ts with the Poirier win but the Siver fight was basically a giant Conor commercial for the American public to be introduced too him on prime time TV, and right after the New England Patriots won the AFC championship. It worked too, as the card broke all kinds of records and it was loaded with Irish fighters for the Irish populated Boston fans to gas up.
Holloway and DP were maybe not the same fighters as they are now, but both went on streaks after the loss to Conor and they were legit tests. That sword cuts both ways too, as THAT Conor was probably also a lot better than the one now who got spilled by silk sheets, took two years off, even retired (according to Kavanagh), and changed into a booze artist and an uncontrollable drug addict - a far cry from the bright eyed "60 g's baby!" Conor that was so beloved originally.
The point is, by the time Conor made it to Aldo, he earned it and then some, and even if he fought Aldo post Poirier there are dozens of examples of less earned ts - - - and keep in mind, Conor was also Europe's first "champ-champ" before he even got to the UFC as well, kinda like how Chandler only needed one win owing to his success outside the UFC. He could have sat out 189 but he said to Lorenzo pick who you want, and Lorenzo picked Chad as he thought he was the more stiff test and he was higher ranked. A lot of criticisms can be made of Conor, especially this post Mayweather version, but it just seems that the wrong criticisms are often made owing to some people's disdain for Conor (i.e. "ducker", "took the easy road", "cherry picker", "only fought midgets" etc).
Good post tho!