- Joined
- Jan 7, 2011
- Messages
- 4,063
- Reaction score
- 2,446
Most people would say BJ but if you ask them who would win a fight between BJ and Edgar, all of them would say Edgar, lol.
fighting at WW, lyoto, or w/e is completely irrelevant to be GOAT in a division. it makes him better as an overall fighter or a claim at one of the greats, but "that's it"
can't give it to BJAs great as BJ is/was I always feel like he wasted his talent despite what he accomplished.
Wait. You brought it up in a discussion forum. It's clearly debatable.BJ or Edgar and I don't think it's debatable.
Khabib? lmao
Everyone says BJ
But yet when topics ask about the very best 5 or so fighters in the world, his name rarely comes up
He "literally dominated" a division with 3 title defenses?Obviously BJ Penn. He was a LW and WW champion and literally dominated a division much like Anderson, GSP, and Aldo did.
He's more goat than MM & Cruz, though Dom is right behind him imo
Most people would say BJ but if you ask them who would win a fight between BJ and Edgar, all of them would say Edgar, lol.
BJ won the first fight.
He beat Kenflo, Sanchez, Stevenson, Sherk, Uno, and Serra.He "literally dominated" a division with 3 title defenses?
Only 3 title defenses doe.He beat Kenflo, Sanchez, Stevenson, Sherk, Uno, and Serra.
He also beat Matt Hughes twice who was the 170 champ for years. He also has fought world class talent and was successful throughout his career.
Much more than what you can say about MM or Cruz imo