Does anyone here feel sympathetic for Tom Aspinall?

Does anyone here feel sympathetic for Tom Aspinall?


  • Total voters
    147
Maybe your right, but MAYBE his father shouldn't be popping off about not resigning and going to BOX either.
I am with you there, but they gotta do something themselves. All Dana did was siphon the turinabol from Jones' roid addled flacid penis for two years, and then when finally announced Tom was champ they did in the most shitty way possible. So they cant be trusted.
 
I've worn glasses since I was 6, but I guess anyone that has normal vision just wouldn't understand. Compromised eyesight sucks fucking ass, and you never realize how important it actually is until you can't see properly, or at all.

I don't know if Tom is exaggerating or not, but I know 100% he was fucking hurting in the moment. You couldn't not be. It wasn't Gane who was disadvantaged from then onwards, and he had nothing to lose. Only the champ was risking anything at all in that fight. I don't like how it ended, but it is what it is. I agree with Tom.
 
And plus now Tom has to do double eye surgery.
He literally just claimed that he was getting surgery on the right eye only. And that is the eye that his personal doctor claimed was where he suffered the broken orbital and not the so-called 'knuckle-deep' eye.

Just so we can try to keep the facts straight, fair?
 
I wonder if it was the other way around, if it was Tom Aspinall who gouged Cyril Gane and Gane ended up choosing to stop the fight because of the injuries he sustained because of an illegal strike.

I wonder if people will be on Gane about not continuing fighting if the roles were changed.
Yup. I remember how badly Aljo was clowned after Yan kneed his dome into Bolivian.
 
So people are asking if they should feel sympathy for Tom Aspinall? Tom Aspinall would probably tell you that what happened to him was unfortunate. A freak occurrence. An accident. Maybe even blame Cyril Gane. I look at it differently. I look at it from the standpoint that the referee didn’t fail Tom Aspinall. Cyril Gane didn’t fail Tom Aspinall. The MMA gods didn’t fail Tom Aspinall. I truly believe that Tom Aspinall failed Tom Aspinall. And when he looks in the mirror, deep down, he knows it.

He's got to take responsibility for reality. Fights are chaotic. Hands are open. Ranges are misjudged. If you build your entire claim to greatness on being “the most complete heavyweight on earth,” then part of that completeness is protecting yourself at all times. You don’t get to brag about elite fundamentals and then act shocked when fundamentals matter. Eye pokes don’t happen in a vacuum. They happen because of stance, distance, reactions, and awareness. All controllable variables. Or at least they are if you’re who you say you are.

Not every outcome is fair. Nobody’s saying that. But when something goes wrong, champions adapt. They don’t immediately collapse into victimhood and ask for absolution from the internet. There’s a long-standing expectation in this sport: if you’re going to wear the crown, you accept the consequences that come with being in there. The cage doesn’t owe you sympathy. The division doesn’t pause because things didn’t go your way.

What surprises me is that Aspinall is supposedly this modern, evolved heavyweight, this thinking fighter, this technician. Yet somehow the responsibility never circles back to him. It’s always circumstance. Always bad luck. Always something external. That’s strange, because truly elite fighters have always understood that accountability is part of the job. You don’t outsource it.

So no, I don’t feel sympathy. Because at the end of the day, nothing was taken from him. Nothing was stolen. There was no grand injustice. There was a moment, and in that moment, he wasn’t prepared for everything that could happen in a fight.

Tom Aspinall didn’t get screwed.
Tom Aspinall screwed Tom Aspinall.
 
The criticisms aren't for getting injured, it's his attitude for the last few years. Owed the world but makes no effort to market himself. Begs for life changing fights but shows almost no intrest in actually fighting. And now? Dialing up the cringe factor to 11, dropping fake AI diagnosis, and letting his dad do the talking for him.
 
The criticisms aren't for getting injured, it's his attitude for the last few years. Owed the world but makes no effort to market himself. Begs for life changing fights but shows almost no intrest in actually fighting. And now? Dialing up the cringe factor to 11, dropping fake AI diagnosis, and letting his dad do the talking for him.
his fans will always pretend that it is though. There's no getting through to them on that.
 
Anyone who doesn't feel sympathy for Tom is half an a$$hole.

The guy had to waste half his prime waiting for a JBJ fight, then got fouled by Gane, and now may never fight again, may have to have eye surgery, and to top it all off he got raked under the coals by many fans and also his dipshit boss.

And somehow he's the bad guy?????

Seriously, anyone who is still on the "Tom quit" train should be beaten half to death by their mother-in-law.
 
Last edited:
So people are asking if they should feel sympathy for Tom Aspinall? Tom Aspinall would probably tell you that what happened to him was unfortunate. A freak occurrence. An accident. Maybe even blame Cyril Gane. I look at it differently. I look at it from the standpoint that the referee didn’t fail Tom Aspinall. Cyril Gane didn’t fail Tom Aspinall. The MMA gods didn’t fail Tom Aspinall. I truly believe that Tom Aspinall failed Tom Aspinall. And when he looks in the mirror, deep down, he knows it.

He's got to take responsibility for reality. Fights are chaotic. Hands are open. Ranges are misjudged. If you build your entire claim to greatness on being “the most complete heavyweight on earth,” then part of that completeness is protecting yourself at all times. You don’t get to brag about elite fundamentals and then act shocked when fundamentals matter. Eye pokes don’t happen in a vacuum. They happen because of stance, distance, reactions, and awareness. All controllable variables. Or at least they are if you’re who you say you are.

Not every outcome is fair. Nobody’s saying that. But when something goes wrong, champions adapt. They don’t immediately collapse into victimhood and ask for absolution from the internet. There’s a long-standing expectation in this sport: if you’re going to wear the crown, you accept the consequences that come with being in there. The cage doesn’t owe you sympathy. The division doesn’t pause because things didn’t go your way.

What surprises me is that Aspinall is supposedly this modern, evolved heavyweight, this thinking fighter, this technician. Yet somehow the responsibility never circles back to him. It’s always circumstance. Always bad luck. Always something external. That’s strange, because truly elite fighters have always understood that accountability is part of the job. You don’t outsource it.

So no, I don’t feel sympathy. Because at the end of the day, nothing was taken from him. Nothing was stolen. There was no grand injustice. There was a moment, and in that moment, he wasn’t prepared for everything that could happen in a fight.

Tom Aspinall didn’t get screwed.
Tom Aspinall screwed Tom Aspinall.
What a surprise...

A Jones fan throwing shade at the person who was on the receiving end of an eyepoke and trying to blame the victim. What??? Tom didn't work on his eye-poking defence? How many fighters train for that? I want to see that footage please. Would be pure comedy gold. It's not Gane's fault that Tom got eye-poked?

The comedy writes itself.

The "modern, evolved, thinking fighter" exercised his brains and elected not to continue fighting while he was disadvantaged. Do you suggest he continue brawling and risk further injury just to satisfy stupid fans instead? Be real. You're pissed he didn't lose his title too. You have Jones as your AV, and you're blathering on about a champion being noble and shit. Get the fuck out of here with that nonsense, this is pure drivel.

I'm not sure if you used up Joe's supply of weed or alpha brain, but you got something going on, amigo.
 
There are a lot of people criticizing Tom for being fouled and I can't wait for their buttplugs to arrive so they get away from their keyboards for a little bit

cat-cleaning.gif
You think you can't post on sherdog with a buttplug in?
 
Yes. I don't think he handled the situation in the most elegant way but at the end of the day he was the victim in this situation and got treated like the villain. It's a clown social media world where everybody confuses their dumbass opinions with facts.

"hE WaS hOldinG tHe WRonG EyE!!!11"
"HE wAs LoOkINg At tHe RePLaY!!!11"
 
He literally just claimed that he was getting surgery on the right eye only. And that is the eye that his personal doctor claimed was where he suffered the broken orbital and not the so-called 'knuckle-deep' eye.

Just so we can try to keep the facts straight, fair?

Sorry I thought i heard it was double eye surgery. No big deal. Take a chill pill and relax.
 
What a surprise...

A Jones fan throwing shade at the person who was on the receiving end of an eyepoke and trying to blame the victim. What??? Tom didn't work on his eye-poking defence? How many fighters train for that? I want to see that footage please. Would be pure comedy gold. It's not Gane's fault that Tom got eye-poked?

The comedy writes itself.

The "modern, evolved, thinking fighter" exercised his brains and elected not to continue fighting while he was disadvantaged. Do you suggest he continue brawling and risk further injury just to satisfy stupid fans instead? Be real. You're pissed he didn't lose his title too. You have Jones as your AV, and you're blathering on about a champion being noble and shit. Get the fuck out of here with that nonsense, this is pure drivel.

I'm not sure if you used up Joe's supply of weed or alpha brain, but you got something going on, amigo.
I don’t think this is about an eye poke. I think the eye poke is just the excuse.

Because I watched Tom Aspinall build his entire identity around being the smartest heavyweight in the room. The modern one. The evolved one. The thinking fighter who saw things others didn’t. And I watched that same guy spend more time calling out Jon Jones than acknowledging the men actually standing across from him. Legacy talk. Unfinished business talk. Measuring himself against a standard he hadn’t earned proximity to yet.

So then the moment comes. The moment where things don’t go according to script. And suddenly it’s not about evolution anymore. It’s not about answers. It’s about circumstances.

I’ve heard all the justifications before. Nobody did anything wrong. Cyril Gane didn’t commit a sin. The referee didn’t conspire. The universe didn’t single him out. And somehow, in all of this, the only person who’s not allowed to be examined is the man who keeps telling us how complete he is.

I watched him rise. I watched him get the belt. I watched people tell me this was the future. And when that future got interrupted, everyone rushed in to explain why this time the standard shouldn’t apply. Why adversity should be treated as an external injustice instead of part of the job description. You don’t get to have it both ways. You don’t get to spend years presenting yourself as the inevitable answer while quietly lowering the bar the moment reality pushes back.

And here’s the part people don’t want to hear: the fixation on Jones is what makes this sting. Because Jones absorbed chaos, controversy, fouls, bad nights, bad optics, and kept winning. He didn’t get moral exemptions. He didn’t get pauses. He didn’t get the benefit of “understandable circumstances.” He got judged by outcomes.

So when Aspinall talks like he’s already that guy, and then reality intervenes, people notice the gap. Not because they hate him. Not because they’re cruel. But because greatness doesn’t get graded on intent.

You can sympathize with the situation if you want. That’s human. But don’t confuse sympathy with absolution. Because the belt doesn’t care, the division doesn’t care, and history definitely doesn’t care.

That’s not blaming the victim. That’s holding the claimant to the standard he volunteered for.
 
Back
Top