• Xenforo Cloud is upgrading us to version 2.3.8 on Monday February 16th, 2026 at 12:00 AM PST. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

Do You Care When White Actors Play Non White Roles?

Do You Care When White Actors Play Non White Roles


  • Total voters
    60
I am not a fan of changing the race of any character as I have stated before. I think you will rarely see from this point on, white actors replacing minority characters but we do see the opposite. Just leave the source material as is imo.
 
Nah, you should read up about The Conqueror. Not just the fact that they filmed it near a nuclear test site and half the crew got cancer, but about Wayne insisting on doing what he saw as a Chinese Western regardless of the director trying to talk him out of it.
Have you seen any of it? It's not just modern sensibilities or identity politics. Even allowing that it was filmed at a time when interracial marriage was illegal in a lot of US states, people still found the combination of Wayne's characteristic cowboy drawl with the addition of a fu-manchu mustache pretty godawful. Absolutely panned. Can't find a detailed attribution, but Wayne himself is widely reported as having said the moral of the film was, "Not to make an ass of yourself trying to play parts you're not suited for."
So what you've effectively described is casting based on name recognition only as they believed he would have drawn the crowds in.
 
So what you've effectively described is casting based on name recognition only as they believed he would have drawn the crowds in.
No, Dick Powell made it because Wayne insisted, reportedly after Wayne grabbed the script from the trash. Powell thought the script belonged there, and the role was unsuited to Wayne.
 
No, Dick Powell made it because Wayne insisted, reportedly after Wayne grabbed the script from the trash. Powell thought the script belonged there, and the role was unsuited to Wayne.
Just looked at the numbers - it actually did fairly well. Turns out the Duke was the draw after all.
 
I would prefer to see movies that are all white

Or at least if a black is casted, it should only be as a snappy wisecracking supporting character
 
I'm fine with Olivier playing Othello.
6a125a8c49133ca73e24be89a6e3a1be_w200.gif
 
I mean it really depends on a couple variables . Is it a historical film ? Picking say Zac Efron to play Mohatma Ghandi would be a stjpid fucking choice. Picking a southern Italian like Pacino to play a Puerto Rican? I mean that's pretty darn close.
 
I mean it really depends on a couple variables . Is it a historical film ? Picking say Zac Efron to play Mohatma Ghandi would be a stjpid fucking choice. Picking a southern Italian like Pacino to play a Puerto Rican? I mean that's pretty darn close.
Pacino has the look so he gets the pass
 
I mean it really depends on a couple variables . Is it a historical film ? Picking say Zac Efron to play Mohatma Ghandi would be a stjpid fucking choice. Picking a southern Italian like Pacino to play a Puerto Rican? I mean that's pretty darn close.

It really is that simple. Are they trying to (and succeeding to) make it look genuine, that's alright.

Blatant racism in the name of "equality"? Nah. Nobody wants to see a black little mermaid.
 
I mean it really depends on a couple variables . Is it a historical film ? Picking say Zac Efron to play Mohatma Ghandi would be a stjpid fucking choice. Picking a southern Italian like Pacino to play a Puerto Rican? I mean that's pretty darn close.

I think there's two dimensions to the complaints: the look factor and the career/jobs factor.

In the case of Carlito's Way, yeah, Pacino playing a Puerto Rican didn't look off or unrealistic so there's no complaints on that part. But the argument is that there are so few Latino characters in major Hollywood productions that the very few that do get the green light should go to Latino actors. I believe this was John Leguizamo's point when he criticized the casting in this movie.
 
I picked that I don't care but really I care if it detracts or distracts from the movie. I don't care from a moral standpoint, it's acting. Also, I don't care if a person plays a straight person or vice versa. I probably don't care with unknown actors unless it's noticeable. I don't Google the cast. If it's noticable, I'll be annoyed. So unknown "white" who looks the part, yes. Daniel Radcliffe as Shaft, no.

And no, I don't like black face or Breakfast At Tiffany's style things.
 
I am a fan of reading history and I enjoy historical dramas and action done well. Elements that are inaccurate and ahisorical bother me and bring me out if the immersion. So I appreciate attempts to cast actors as accurate as possible from a visual perspective. I don't care at all if any groups are offended by representation.
 
Tom Cruise in Last Samurai really rubbed me the wrong way
 
Back
Top