How would he have faired if he moved up when JDS, Werdum, Mir, Cain, Overeem, and Cro Cop were all in the mix?
Edit - this is not a diss against Gane. He is a beast and I’m excited to see what he brings. I also think there are some other intriguing matchups for Jones currently at heavyweight as well.
Ya he was smart to wait. Less skilled grapplers now.
Werdum mops the floor with him. Better striking and grappling.
Mir is the same as above.
JDS too big, fast and strong, good enough grappling defense. It depends on how much JBJ cardio holds up. Winnable for Jones similar to Gane but not as east
Cain healthy would pose problems due to wrestling acumen which cancels JBJ grappling but he is short for HW. It would likely look similar to Reyes v Jones
Stipe old now but back then too big, fast, good enough wrestling defense and much better striker.
Overeem same as stipe but even taller with more reach which poses more problems for JBJ. Rumor has it he owned Jones at Greg Jackson's
Crocop was too old at that point. OWGP Crocop likely breaks JBJ legs with kicks. Cage is always an X factor with Crocop though. He's lateral movements was better suited for ring.
Jones has beaten better strikers, grapplers and moxes of the two than the list above but they were all shorter than him with much less reach.
He looked extremely average, beatable and arguably lost to less skilled fighters who were closer to his size.
JBJ relatively slow for LHW but overcomes that and skill gap with reach and height leverage (grappling) Both are gone at HW. Now he can just grapple to win though since there are only strikers at the top