Good game. I've been using it as a time killer.
I have never played on of the Demon Souls and related games before. I DO like the challenge but will confess a lot of my deaths just feel too cheap, mainly because either 1) it's a camera fuck up / lock on issue, or 2) when locked on to an opponent I feel my character gets to slow, but if I lock off I can free roam but wind up swinging in directions I don't want / struggle to hone in on an enemy.
So I'm not in love with the game for that reason, but I am enjoying it a lot. I do find it rather tedious and repetitive at times too, though that does make for some intense and gratifying times as well. It's an 8.5 out of 10 for me. I've managed to beat Cleric, Gascoigne, Blood Drained, the 2 Witches in the main quest, as well as the Vicar and some of the first bosses in the first chalice dungeon tho I def should have waited til my guy was more powerful (gave up on battling the flaming dog).
The game changer for me (perhaps due to my lack of experience) was not knowing you couldn't level up until getting an unseen/reaching first boss, that running past enemies was such a viable and common tactic, and starting with a character very low on vitality.
Knowing about those basics would have saved me some frustration.