All Time GOAT poll

laziest thread this year so far. Next lets talk about fighter pay.....oh, or how much of an *sshole Dana is....Or even better, how Sherdoggers think they have a new clever way of saying WMMA sucks. Classic stuff right there
 
I think Jon beats any version of Fedor but that's me.

I think Jon is the endboss in MMA
 
Jones needs to beat Stipe, Pav, Aspinall and 1 more serious contender before entering the HW GOAT chat

Overall GOAT it goes to Fedones.

Fedor has the * for never fighting in the UFC (he did fight AA and Tim though)

Jones has the * for pissing hot multiple times and dodging tests
 
BowserJr said:
Jones needs to beat Stipe, Pav, Aspinall and 1 more serious contender before entering the HW GOAT chat

Overall GOAT it goes to Fedones.

Fedor has the * for never fighting in the UFC (he did fight AA and Tim though)

Jones has the * for pissing hot multiple times and dodging tests
Click to expand...

And his brother even pissed hot. I don't believe in Jones when he says he didn't take anything.
 
Clark Rogers said:
Was he ever tested prior to Bellator?

Serious question, Pride wasn't exactly a pillar of fair sport. Not accusing him of anything, just sayin can't piss hot if never asked to piss to begin with.
Click to expand...

NSAC tested him when he fought Mark Coleman for Pride 32. If you don't believe NSAC tested fighters in Pride FC Nick Diaz came up dirty for his Pride 33 fight which got turned into a NC.
 
Two completely different eras, each was amazing for their time period in the sport.
 
As always, depends on criteria. For me, I think Fedor was greater was greater because he was more active. Not enough fans appreciate the fact that the more they fight, the greater the chance of losing. Part of the reason Jones’ record is so great is because he’s fought less.
 
G10 said:
As always, depends on criteria. For me, I think Fedor was greater was greater because he was more active. Not enough fans appreciate the fact that the more they fight, the greater the chance of losing. Part of the reason Jones’ record is so great is because he’s fought less.
Click to expand...
Agreed. This is huge.

Fedor entered many tournaments.

Fedor would also fight multiple times in one night.

He would also fight again just a month or two later.

He has fought 5x in one calendar year before.

He has twice as many fights as Jones.
 
  • Like
Reactions: G10
Stan said:
NSAC tested him when he fought Mark Coleman for Pride 32. If you don't believe NSAC tested fighters in Pride FC Nick Diaz came up dirty for his Pride 33 fight which got turned into a NC.
Click to expand...

Is this a joke ? They never tested anyone in Japan.

This event was in the USA.
 
Jones pp jerkers delusional in thinking the cage hider would be in this discussion if it weren’t for his masterclass cheat sheet
 
I just don’t see how anyone ranks anyone above GSP at this point, it’s not even close.

2 losses in his entire career that he later avenged, retired with the WW belt after defending it numerous times, came back after 3 years to win the MW belt.

Silva and Jones both got popped so while I’ll still rank them the MW and LHW Goats they can never be the number 1 overall. Fedor is still the HW belt but taking all those L’s at the end of his career (Mitrione come on man) knocks him down below GSP.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,275,198
Messages
57,973,907
Members
175,888
Latest member
whatsername

Share this page

Back
Top