• Xenforo is upgrading us to version 2.3.7 on Tuesday Aug 19, 2025 at 01:00 AM BST (date has been pushed). This upgrade includes several security fixes among other improvements. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

All Time GOAT poll

Fedor Emelianenko is the best HW in MMA History. Stipe Miocic is the best UFC HW in history and the 2nd best behind.... Fedor
 
Paolo Delutis said:
Jones wins and now HW is shit lol..


Maybe i dunno..


Crazy thought..



But maybe just maybe Jones is simply that good..



The guy was world champion at 23 and never lost after that...

That's Tyson/Mayweather type shit...it really shouldn't of been such a surprise for everyone.
.

If u actually knew what u were watching ofcourse...the experience of Jones is all he'd ever need to beat a guy like Gane... Gane thought he was safe but didn't respect Jones craftiness and got tapped...
Click to expand...
People are twisting themselves in knots to avoid these facts.
 
I'm not a big Jones fan but I observe a lot of Jones Derangement Syndrome here on the Dog. He's been demolishing one generation after another of fighters. It's amazing.
 
BFoe said:
GOAT HW? He’d have to beat Fedor’s accomplishments. He’d need 12 ranked HW wins, 5 total HW title defenses, without a loss.
Doesn’t seem likely.
Click to expand...

Let me remind everyone that Jon:

Failed multiple PED tests.
Is using eypokes.
Does drugs.
Fucks hookers.
Beats his wife.
Crashed multiple cars.
Almost killed a pregnant woman.
Slammed his head on a police car.
...etc

Fedor on the other hand never did anything like that. Worst thing that Fedor did was putting some ice betwixt Mussasi`s butt cheeks.

There is no denying Jones accomplishments inside the cage, but those alone are not enough to consider him GOAT. Taking everything into consideration, GSP is more of a GOAT than Jones ever will be. It absolutely doesnt matter what Jon`s future accomplishments at HW are, he ruined his chance of ever becoming a GOAT looooong time ago.
 
Last edited:
Fedor beat the best HWs of his generation in their prime when they were in their 20s. These HWs would be elite HWs today.

Jones just beat a French kickboxer with no ground and is now cherry picking 42 year old CTE Stipe who got flattened in his last fight and hasn't fought in 2 years. Neither of these guys are elite today.

The low standards for GOAT you see from U FIGHT CHEAP fans is amusing.
 
Last edited:
Beat stipe
Beat a new breed
Then it's good enough for me
Would like to see him break the defense record but it's not happening
 
Lee_ said:
ROFL Sherdog really on fire with Jon today.
Click to expand...
Haters. Jones is the best all time. Fedor a close second imo. Fedor should have retired years ago. The rest are far behind, steroids or not.
 
yaco787 said:
How could the UFC heavyweight div be so weak that Stipe is the best HW of alltime?

Not counting HW that never came to UFC, i would still say Arlovski had a better run and maybe even mere.

Jone jones will walk thru stipe.
Click to expand...

The claim is based on the number of defenses which is impressive.

Aside from that beating Werdum, Ngannou and DC is great too

Reem was still decent though not in his prime, same for JDS to a lesser extent.

It's a shame we never saw a Werdum rematch or fights with prime Reem, JDS, Cain

Would've loved to see all those vs Jones too
 
Last edited:
DS7 said:
Excluding the japanese pro wrestlers and the Zululinhos that Fedor fought in between his Pride run, he has about 8 or 10 legit wins there which is great


How many wins do you think Jones needs since he will add great names to his resume like Gane, Miocic, Blaydes, Pavlovich etc?
Click to expand...
I think if he moved up to heavyweight 5 years ago he could be 10-0 at that weight and be in convo with Fedor as best heavyweight. Jon is best fighter all time, but best HW imo is Fedor
 
DS7 said:
Excluding the japanese pro wrestlers and the Zululinhos that Fedor fought in between his Pride run, he has about 8 or 10 legit wins there which is great


How many wins do you think Jones needs since he will add great names to his resume like Gane, Miocic, Blaydes, Pavlovich etc?
Click to expand...
Hw goat record is 4 title defences so jones will need 4 more wins
 
Prime HW has passed. So he needs 7 wins. The POS.

<CanYouSeeMeNow>
 
To be the greatest UFC HW champion I guess he needs to defend the belt at least 4 times to match which would include beating him head to head.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,271,221
Messages
57,705,993
Members
175,813
Latest member
Omidullah81

Share this page

Back
Top