Aldo , MM, Nog , Hendo

[KAZSoliloquy]

P4P lists made by MMA websites are garbage

Mark Hominick is a more skilled fighter than anyone Hendo or Nog ever fought

oh ok.

 

[Hotei]

Hard to answer without set criterias.

If we are going for iconic and memorable:

Nog
Hendo
Aldo
..
..
MM

Success relative to their competition
MM
..
Aldo
Nog
..
Hendo

 

[Redwood101]

Mighty Mouse
Aldo
Big Nog
Hendo

 

[sonhow]

Aldo
Hendo
Nog
MM

 

[Cooliox]

Hendo was simultaneously the MW Champion, and LHW Champion...

Hendo also defeated the top 2 HW GOATs in Fedor and Big Nog.

Enough said.

 

[WHITE ANDERSON]

MM is the GOAT of MMA
nog got wrecked by frank mir in all aspects of MMA
Aldo only needed 13 seconds to slip on his own piss and throw his career away
Hendo was on all the TRT and couldn't even beat jake shields

thanks for come to my TED TALK

 

[Gambit MMA]

Aldo
MM
Hendo
Nog

 

[MartinGibson86]

aldo has beaten 1 p4p ranked fighter ever. frankie edgar. nog and henderson have beaten multiple.

Nog has beaten zero p4p all timers.

Zero

Unless you count the smaller Hendo

Werdum too I guess

 

[the ambush]

Hendo
Big Nog
Aldo
Mighty Mouse

 

[KAZSoliloquy]

Nog has beaten zero p4p all timers.

Zero

Unless you count the smaller Hendo

mark coleman & cro cop were both ranked P4P

 

[updowniri]

MM
Hendo
Aldo
Nog

 

[MartinGibson86]

mark coleman & cro cop were both ranked P4P

Neither are close to all time p4p level.

Not even top 10 in their own historically weak weightclass.

 

[HARDCORE CHINO]

Aldo
Hendo
Nog
MM

Just based on level of competition they were facing. I am not angry at any arrangement as they are all legends

 

[RockyLockridge]

MM
Aldo
Hendo
Nog

It's close between aldo and MM, but i can't argue against mighty mouse his win over cejudo and benavidez really have aged well

Mighty Mouse
Aldo
Big Nog
Hendo

Mighty Mouse is arguably the greatest fighter of all time.

I'm inclined to side with this it's a very tough statement to debate.

Common arguments to the contrary include
"he never fought anyone!"
he's fought plenty of top guys, cejudo twice(x2 ufc champ, olympic medalist), benividez twice (3x flw title challenger, 1xbw title challenger in wec), Dominic cruz, Dodson x2 (wins over dillashaw), kyoji horiguchi (considered the best fighter at ATT) That's plenty of good high quality defenses, even leaving the cariasos, moragas, and borg's off the list.

"he borring"
Yet he has more finishes than jones in less defenses.

He is by far the most underrated in terms of these goat conversations.