Aldo , MM, Nog , Hendo

[r-harper-1]

how would you rank them all time ?

Aldo
Hendo
Nog
MM

Imo

 

[Sweater of AV]

Nog
Hendo
Aldo
MM

Aldo and MM are obviously the GOATs of FW and FlyW respectively. Nog and Hendo couldn't give a flying fuck about weight classes though and were still extremely successful.

 

[jnes]

Hendo, Aldo then the other 2.

 

[Matthew Fedler]

MM
Aldo
Nog
Hendo

 

[TheSpider]

Aldo
MM
Hendo
Big Nog

 

[Calipwnia]

Very hard but Aldo MM tier 1
Hendo Nog tier 1.5

 

[BFoe]

Rank them all time, like on a GOAT list?
1. Aldo
2. MM
3. Nog
4. Hendo

 

[pick999]

mm...2nd greatest ufc fighter after jon

 

[Prima Donald]

MM
Aldo
Nog
Hendo

Same, based on what the thread starter asked not who I would prefer to watch.

 

[Shaddows]

Nog
Hendo
Aldo
MM

Aldo and MM are obviously the GOATs of FW and FlyW respectively. Nog and Hendo couldn't give a flying fuck about weight classes though and were still extremely successful.

pretty much this...

 

[Fight Professor]

That is a tough one.

Rating based on the opponent quality:

Nog
Hendo
Aldo
MM

Rating based on their accomplishments in the dvision, which is almost the reverse order:

MM
Aldo
Nog
Hendo

I feel like the order for me would be as follows. But there is really no wrong answer here.

Aldo
Nog
MM
Hendo

 

[LEWIS540]

Hendo is actually really hard to rank.

Inconsistent, weight jumping, the TRT thing. At the same time he’s got an incredible list of opponents with a very respectable w/l records.

 

[Bruce Lee666]

Hendo is my favorite, always fun to watch.

Hendo is the kind of warrior who doesn't fear death, tough guy.

I don't care about ranking!

 

[LEWIS540]

That is a tough one.

Rating based on the opponent quality:

Nog
Hendo
Aldo
MM

That had to be a slam dunk for Hendo surely?

Hendo’s opponent list is the greatest in history, I’d have to think.

 

[Fight Professor]

That had to be a slam dunk for Hendo surely?

Hendo’s opponent list is the greatest in history, I’d have to think.

The issue is he lost to a lot of those opponents - Vitor, Machida, Rampage, Arona, both Nogs (+ a close decision win against Big Nog), 1-1 against Wand, and obviously losses to Silva and DC.

Nog only lost to Fedor in PRIDE and is 1-1 against Barnett in close fights. He also got the UFC interim title.

 

[Iron Nick]

Mighty Mouse
Aldo
Big Nog
Hendo

Mighty Mouse is arguably the greatest fighter of all time.

 

[bartleby929]

MM Aldo Nog Hendo

 

[dildos]

Aldo
MM
Hendo
Big Nog

Wrong. Not surprised you are not correct with your choices.

 

[LEWIS540]

The issue is he lost to a lot of those opponents - Vitor, Machida, Rampage, Arona, both Nogs (+ a close decision win against Big Nog), 1-1 against Wand, and obviously losses to Silva and DC.

Nog only lost to Fedor in PRIDE and is 1-1 against Barnett in close fights. He also got the UFC interim title.

I thought you were talking just opponent list, not the w/l.

 

[Roljo]

mm...2nd greatest ufc fighter after jon

He fought mostly semi pro fighters though...