- Joined
- Mar 31, 2008
- Messages
- 43,423
- Reaction score
- 43,825
Well I'm not particularly interested in myself or my family getting attacked in any capacity, so trading my rights for a higher rate of other crimes doesn't exactly sound like a great deal.How seriously did you interrogate the two sources of data?
Is this a face value interpretation?
Because if you're right, and the UK "is more violent" than the USA, the fact the USA has a far higher murder rate is a perfect argument against guns. They would, theoretically, make far less violence far more deadly.
Is that your argument by extension?
Your source is a wordpress blog from 11 years ago? Even that book report says the number is higher for the UK, then declares he doesn't like that, so he cherry picks a couple categories, two of which are already the 2 smallest but massive overlap(homicides and "fatal shootings" as 2 separate categories).See my edit.
Not sure why car theft was a category, but the 2 countries are not even close in car ownership. Yeah, no shit you aren't going to have a car stolen when you don't own a car. The US has 908 cars/1000 people, and the UK has 600, so even according to that guy's numbers, cars are stolen more often in the UK when you divide by the number of cars instead of the number of people who don't even own a car.
From your own source...
So:
UK: 821,957 / 561 = 1465
US: 1,203,564 / 3116 = 386
Pretty generous of him to use only assault cases where the person is left permanently disabled or disfigured for the UK to compare to ones in the US that don't require any harm or to even touch the other person. Lol at pretending the number is only 19,000. Here are the actual comparable numbers for what would qualify as aggravated assault if they were in the US. The guy is off by orders of magnitude.
The nature of violent crime in England and Wales - Office for National Statistics
A summary of violent crime from the Crime Survey for England and Wales and police recorded crime.
www.ons.gov.uk
- "violence without injury" accounted for 41% (732,912 offences)
- "violence with injury" accounted for 31% (540,502 offences)
- "stalking and harassment" accounted for 28% (494,586)
Last edited: