I tried... really tried to get into Krav Maga. Here is MY experience with it.
I had been looking for a new place to train, and one of the places I checked out was a KM gym. I wanted to both see what all the hype was about and see if I had anything I could gain from training there, so me and a buddy took a trip down and audited the class. Here is a rough breakdown of that experience.
The class started with a short run, the instructor had all of the students run to the end of the block and back, yes, that is right, a single block, not around the block, not past the block, but to the end and back. This is what served as the warm-up. Not exactly a brilliant start, but, I wasn’t always a fan of the warm-ups at my previous gym either and mostly handled conditioning/strength on my own.
From there we were paired up with students and instructed on the first of many “knee to the balls” drills. Our “opponent” was expected to hold up a suitcase pad at abdomen level, pretend to punch us and we were to “grab the shoulder and knee the pad”. This knee was intended to simulate a knee to the balls, which seemed fair enough, anything short of simulating that would be insane. Most of the focus on this drill was “intensity” the instructor really pushed the students to not only knee the pad, but to knee it like you wanted to hurt the person behind it. However, the instructor didn’t want so much intensity that the person on the other side of the pad grimaced… and in fact he asked me and my friend to “knee with less force” which seemed very contrary to the “knee with intensity” statement. This actually sent up the second red flag for me, as apparently intensity is only good until it causes discomfort.
The rest of the drills were all essentially variations on the knee the balls drill, and towards the end of class my friend and I were getting a little bored of this. At one point, when he wasn’t occupied, I pulled the instructor aside and asked if/when they did sparring for the class. And his response was and I quote “Krav Maga is not about whomping on each other. If you guys want to be tough and whomp on each other go find a MMA class. Krav Maga is about self-defense”. We left after that and frankly, I worry about the people who train there as they were all middle aged women and men, all of whom were out of shape and liable to piss someone off more than successfully defend themselves with the techniques as they were being executed – especially without live resistance in their regular training.
I was a little bit let down, I was hoping for something modern and real world applicable. I left feeling like I had just walked out of a 1990's Karate McDojo.