That's fair. I was willing to date her exclusively if she just asked, but she never did. I have heard that people leave their apps open until they find someone, so that's what I did. Maybe I could have taken the initiative and deleted the apps anyways? Sure. But she said she didn't have a physical attraction for me, so perhaps that wouldn't have done anything.
If she asked? Why didn't you ask if you liked her? You're the man, right?
And why did you even tell her that you were still on Tinder/other dating apps if you guys were talking like you were about to get into some kind of relationship? Why even bring that up?
If I was talking to a girl for a few MONTHS, and i liked her, and it felt like she liked me, and then she starts talking about being on Tinder, then i'd be like WTF are we doing here then? You are the one that fucked up here.
And why are you guys talking for MONTHS and nothing happened? It sounds like you were already in the friend zone.
Another thing, about the physical attraction, a lot of guys don't seem to get that guys and girls think VERY differently about this. A girl does not need to be physically attracted to you to want you. And what girls say they want/think they want, often times does not match up to what they REALLY want, or what they are willing to accept. A girl can be with a fat guy, an ugly guy, a nerd, an old guy, and GENUINELY care and love the guy--that would not so quickly happen with a guy and a fat/ugly/old girl.
Girls are naturally a lot more sensitive and self-conscious than guys are. The hottest girl in the world will call herself fat, or think she's ugly on some days. When she has a guy who is always on point in his fitness, diet, hair, style, etc...it just increases the pressure on her.
Girls like LOOKING at Brad Pitt, fucking Brad Pitt, but most of them don't want to marry him.