Call me crazy but if she's a woman, she would probably not want this kind of public attention, lol. She might privately like that she's..... "appreciated"...... enough to garner this kind of attention but it would be really weird having scores of creeps in a chat talking to you about another creep's crush on you, lol.
There have got to be 200 messages here aimed at her directly or indirectly and it would be very overwhelming for a woman to wade into this and try responding to them. And if she was a woman, how emotionally bankrupt would she need to be to want to spend her energy trying to "provide proof" of her womanhood to a bunch of Neolithic strangers on a karate forum?
But what if she was a man who was purposefully duping us for kicks? Well then, she'd LOVE the attention and be here trolling everyone.
Her response to this thread is also consistent with being a woman.
But, question, why does anyone suspect she's a man? Just because she posts on Sherdog?