- Joined
- Apr 29, 2012
- Messages
- 45,718
- Reaction score
- 22,205
I get that you're kind of shit posting (and no judgement there; we all do from time to time), but you do get that you're failing to connect your "WPEM" stuff, right?
Andy Capp (don't know the other one you're referring to) is clearly not all that racially ideological, let alone a self-hating white person or anti-white at all. And it's very rare that I ever even see you point out a post by anyone that is anti-white. At most, some stooge will post a Breitbart-style article or a random tweet from some nobody and you'll make a general statement about WPEM's and how they're all going to rush to defend it....and the no one does. Hell, just yesterday (or this morning?) tonni was being singled out as the "only leftist," and tonni is not very socially progressive.
You acknowledged that I'm one of the more "extreme" posters here, so I figured I would take your "litmus test" on the subject:
1) do you believe in CRT?So I get about 3, but I'm
Answer: Yes, I guess? It's kind of a hard question to answer. I don't think the framework is infallible, that it can explain everything, or that it isn't misused, but I think it uncovers a lot of truth and bears a lot of valuable analysis. It's frankly not super relevant. No high school teachers are doing sections on Critical Race Theory. Hell, even as a social science major in college, I only came across it in a couple classes and didn't see anything super scandalous. It just studies phenomena that correlate to race along the lines of racial confrontation, domination, and norm-creation.2) do you believe only white people can be racist?
Answer: No, not how you are meaning it. When most (99%) of people talk about "racism," they are talking broadly about prejudice, animus, and discrimination along the lines of racial identity. Of course, using that more liberal definition, everyone can be (or is) racist. If someone is using the sociological concept of racism as those things plus institutional power, I think it's fair to say "only [the ethnic/racial group in power] can be racist."3) do you believe in Defund the police?
Answer: Yes, but this is again super vague. I don't believe in abolishing the police, but I do think that, particularly at the municipal level, bloated police expenditures (think, advanced weaponry and equipment that never gets used) could be better served being allocated toward social services. Don't you agree?4) do you kneecap your own opinions and start off by saying, "as a white Cis-gender male..."
Answer: Yes - well, no one says that in regard to everything. But I do think it's important for one to acknowledge their own experiential limitations. If someone asks me about discrimination against immigrants or transgender persons, I can give my opinion but there's no harm in my acknowledging that I've never been an immigrant or a transgender person. Don't you agree?5) Do you pay heed to Ibram Kendi or Robin D'Angelo?
Answer: No. That one was pretty easy.6) do you believe Asians benefit from "white privilege?"
Answer: No, but it's another complicated question depending on how you conceptualize "white privilege." In a few ways, as I've stated here before, Asian Americans suffer uniquely from lack of political representation.
I never had a beef with you, because despite disagreeing with you on host of matters, your positions are usually supported by sound thought and reason.
in regards to # 4, I'm going to pull that from my litmus test for the reasons you explained.