Who is the greatest fighter of all time?

[Jorge Luis Borges]

The wording confused me a bit. let me see if I can sort this out.

Not sure if serious or stupid.

It is your position that if I'm joking I'm stupid, but if I'm serious I'm not.

Beating TRTIR/TRT- Sonnen/Bader(KingMO) or Mitrione
is not in same fucking dimension as beating USADA Bisping who happens to be older than Mir.

So you are saying that Fedor beating Sonnen would not only be greater than GSP beating Bisping, but would be so much greater as to be in another fucking dimension.

I must say, I disagree.

 

[Jorge Luis Borges]

Fedor
GSP
Aldo
MM

Both Jones & Silva have been ruled out of the GOAT convo sadly.

Jones should be Number 1 but unfortunately due to multiple failed drug tests that include Steroids, Turinabol, Clomiphene & Letrozole.

Anderson Silva should be Number 2 but unfortunately due to multiple failed drug tests that include Drostanolone and Androsterone.

Meh, I disagree. It takes a naive person to think a hyper-competitive Russian whose prime years were in an org that encouraged PED use was clean. The problem with his test failures isn't that it puts him in a separate moral category, it is that he has stupidly been wasting his best years. To me Jones has every bit the same claim these other guys have based on resume.

 

[Maladroit]

Rickson

 

[BEATDOWNS]

GSP he fought the toughest competition most consistently. imo

 

[streetglider]

#1

Fedor Emelienenko

Undefeated for 10 years with 31 wins and only lost one round! 24 finishes during that time 6 over former ufc champions plus the pride champion and the pride owgp winner. Also beat k1 champions elite grapplers and guys that were extremely bigger than him. Lost one round in his 7th fight, after that he won every round during that streak in dominant fashion. There was never an argument about whether he won or not. He dominated everyone his first 31 fights.


#2

GSP

25 wins 5 over former UFC champions. Has the most top 10 wins and won in dominating fashion majority of the time. Lost 2 rounds to Hendricks and arguably one to condit. Won belts in 2 weightclasses. Has many decision wins. Avenged all losses.


#3

Jon jones

Undefeated for 8 years with 22 wins over 5 former champions. 15 finishes and lots of dominant performances. Lost 1 round to machida and rashad, lost 2 rounds to DC and Gus. Still undefeated.


#4

Anderson Silva

Won 17 in a row over 4 former ufc champions and the pride champion. Had success moving up to Lhw even beat a former champ and looked flawless doing it. Took lots of chances to finish but often lost rounds because of it. Dominant champion with lots of finishes.


#5

Jose Aldo

25 wins over 4 former UFC/wec champions with 1 loss during that time. Lost one round to Florian, Edgar, and Mendes in their 2nd fight. Dominant champion with 16 finishes. Still young w potential to add to this resume


#6

Mighty Mouse

25wins with 14 finishes. Dominant champion and only lost when he came up in weight. Had a debatable fight over Ian McCall but came back and beat him decisively.




*before its brought up I want to mention both fedor and jones have losses during their undefeated runs. Fedors loss should've been a dq win for him under the rules of the fight. And jones was winning his fight as well. Fedor proved to be the dominant fighter and we all know jones is superior to Hamill. The majority of fans agree neither guy should have that loss on their record.

DANIEL CORMIER has to be in there.

 

[MMAandBOXINGfan]

A combination of these three men - 1A, 1B, 1C

Anderson
Fedor
GSP

Anderson
GSP
Fedor

GSP
Fedor
Anderson

GSP
Anderson
Fedor

Fedor
Anderson
GSP

Fedor
GSP
Anderson

Honorable mention:

Jon Jones
Mighty Mouse
Jose Aldo

 

[DeathByCaranos]

1. Fedor
2. Yuki Nakai
3. Dan Henderson
4. Sakuraba
5. GSP

 

[HHJ]

I get that it feels good to be a Fedor fan right now. But it's not him.

Always was.

 

[Jorge Luis Borges]

Always was.

I respect that opinion.

 

[JoshR86]

Fedor

Past prime Fedor just stiffened TRT Mir (who outweighed Fedor by 20+ pounds) in less than 1 minute.

Only Fedor fans....

GSP comes back after 4 years and wins MW belt.

But somehow that it less impressive than Fedor beating a guy who hasn' fought in 2 years and is 2-6 since 2012....

 

[Dbreiden83080]

The top 3 are

GSP
Fedor
Jones

And that is not necessarily in order. It’s just a good argument. But those are the top three.

 

[Dbreiden83080]

Fedor

Past prime Fedor just stiffened TRT Mir (who outweighed Fedor by 20+ pounds) in less than 1 minute.

Frank has no chin whatsoever. In his prime he showed he could not take a punch.

 

[Dbreiden83080]

Cool, but I think beating 38 years old Kangaroo Meat 260 lb roided to the gills Mir is way better than beating 39 years old weight cut USADA Bisping.

Considering Frank’s record in the last number of years. No not really. Frank pretty much sucks at this point LOL. I mean he really sucks.

 

[Dbreiden83080]

Only Fedor fans....

GSP comes back after 4 years and wins MW belt.

But somehow that it less impressive than Fedor beating a guy who hasn' fought in 2 years and is 2-6 since 2012....

Frank in the prime of his career in the best shape of his life. He got the beating of his life against a professional wrestler at UFC 100. That is real. People might not want to knowledge it. But it happened.

 

[Shishio]

i learned a long time ago....right answer is always fedor.

 

[cheesus]

Fedor for me personally, could argue for a case for GSP too.

 

[Summoning]

Considering Frank’s record in the last number of years. No not really. Frank pretty much sucks at this point LOL. I mean he really sucks.

Sure.. and did you see Bisping vs Silva and Hendo 2???
Bisping got his face destroyed and prety much lost both fights. And then he sucked against Gastelum...

 

[Mondo Freaks]

Fedor or GSP

 

[C0NCH3TO]

gsp and fedor. Hard to pick one from both.

 

[cheesus]

Frank in the prime of his career in the best shape of his life. He got the beating of his life against a professional wrestler at UFC 100. That is real. People might not want to knowledge it. But it happened.

Also a freak athlete, absolutely huge, juiced & high level wrestler. He is hardly just a professional wrestler. Brock on his best day beats a lot of high level fighters.