Who is the GOAT?

[DaPunkMinowaMan]

Erm now?

You initially responded to a post that mentioned Anderson lol. What is wrong with you?

No, lil noob... Im not debatin´with ya, Im checkin ur basic knowledge.

Im not questionning your take on Spider, Im questionning ur assertion that:

"Dude with double-digit losses cant be considered to be GOAT"

That´s why I quoted SRR and Armstrong.

In MMA,this can apply to many GOAT candidates.

[sigh]

 

[Perrichet]

No, lil noob... Im not debatin´with ya, Im checkin ur basic knowledge.

Im not questionning your take on Spider, Im questionning ur assertion that:

"Dude with double-digit losses cant be considered to be GOAT"

That´s why I quoted SRR and Armstrong.

In MMA,this can apply to many GOAT candidates.

[sigh]

So you decide to mention 2 irrelevant people to what I was talking about?

[sigh]

 

[Otto!]

Glad to see that Cokehead juicer Bones is finally off the radar on GOAT talk.

 

[I Am Legion]

Glad to see that Cokehead juicer Bones is finally off the radar on GOAT talk.

Gotta be careful, with all this talk of fight fixing and PRIDE steroid scandal, might be another name coming off.

 

[DaPunkMinowaMan]

So you decide to mention 2 irrelevant people to what I was talking about?

[sigh]

What is at stake here is your assertion:

"Dude with double-digit losses cant be considered to be GOAT"

U have yet to prove me that SRR & Armstrong are out of the GOAT picture in boxing, for instance.

 

[Perrichet]

What is at stake here is your assertion:

"Dude with double-digit losses cant be considered to be GOAT"

U have yet to prove me that SRR & Armstrong are out of the GOAT picture in boxing, for instance.

There’s nothing at stake as I don’t really care about boxing. Use a more appropoate example or go away

 

[Squintz]

Anderson, Jones and then whoever else.

 

[DaPunkMinowaMan]

There’s nothing at stake as I don’t really care about boxing. Use a more appropoate example or go away

That´s what I imagined...

 

[Readybodisready]

imo DC is more talented than Jones

Lol good one. The only thing you can say is DC has better boxing for a short, stocky puncher, but then Jones would never box like that with his frame(although he did once, against Glover. Showed great inside-boxing skills)so it's pretty useless to split hairs about that. Everything else? There's really nothing DC does better in the octagon. Nothing.

 

[Readybodisready]

Hard to deny GSP.

Dominated his own weightless for years. Beat several different generation of fighters. Retired, came back and beat the current Middleweight champion. He also defended all his losses. I'm pretty sure hes the only one who can say that.

GSP is one of only 3 guys I don't mind people proclaiming as GOAT, I disagree totally but he's got a legit case. GSP has unique accolades.

But not because of the recent Bisping win.

 

[Perrichet]

That´s what I imagined...

OK

 

[JackSchtotll]

GSP by far

 

[PEDS Help me Post]

Gotta be careful, with all this talk of fight fixing and PRIDE steroid scandal, might be another name coming off.

Pride steroid scandal?

Steroids were legal in Pride. How could there be a scandal? lol

 

[Deleted member 501827]

Jones and Anderson should not have more votes than MM

 

[giusti825]

Or moving up in weight beating the MW champion to become a multi divisional champion does it

He never fought Whitaker. By the time he fought Bisping, that belt was toilet paper.

When GSP finally fought Bisping, it had been 693 days since that fake piece of shit belt had been defended against a top ranked MW.

When GSP vacated that giant paper weight championship, it had been 726 days (4 days shy of 2 years) since a top MW had a chance to win it.

 

[TUFNewb]

So it's official.

Sherdog has spoken. The GOAT mma fans have spoken.

GSP = GOAT.

and

Melvin Guillard > Silva.



How will the dick pill fangirls ever recover from this?

 

[tenniswhiz]

Melvin doing awright in this poll!
Cuz of his awesome jitz.

 

[Perrichet]

He never fought Whitaker. By the time he fought Bisping, that belt was toilet paper.

When GSP finally fought Bisping, it had been 693 days since that fake piece of shit belt had been defended against a top ranked MW.

When GSP vacated that giant paper weight championship, it had been 726 days (4 days shy of 2 years) since a top MW had a chance to win it.

Yeah it was toilet paper to you and others who ignore facts

 

[ftpngo]

it took a long time but sherdog finally realises that gsp is the goat

 

[giusti825]

Yeah it was toilet paper to you and others who ignore facts

How long before a title loses its meaning to you? 3 years? 10 years? never?

People arguing that belt was legitimate always have trouble with this one. Or just give a ridiculous answer.

I'd argue that if a belt doesnt lose ite legitimacy after two years with no legitimate defenses, while there is a more legitimate belt, you just really dont care.....the UFC could annoint chris leben champ tomorrow and you'd see no problem with it......some fans have standards however.....