Which career would you erase: Stone Cold vs Undertaker vs Hulk Hogan

Undertaker

Never the guy

Never drew a dime

Never had a good match before 2006 and even then was carried by vastly superior workers

Never cut a memorable promo

Never put anyone over

Never had the balls to step out his WWF comfort even when Ted Turner threw millions at him

Main evented the lowest drawing Wrestlemania of the '90s

Main evented the lowest drawing Wrestlemania of the '10s

Tanked the buyrate of King Of The Ring in 2002 so hard the PPV got cancelled

Was barely ever in the main title picture because he was never a big enough deal

Only the 2nd best member of The Brothers of Destruction

Only the 4th best member of The Ministry

Only the 8th best member of The Corporate Ministry

His backstage clique "The Bone Street Krew" was utterly BTFO by The Kliq and achieved nothing notable except inflicting Savio Vega on us

His biker cosplay was cringeworthy

His MMA cosplay was cringeworthy

Unironically calls himself """"""""DA BEST PURE STRIKER IN DA WWE""""""""

Shit taste in whiskey (this one is actually 100% true, JD is awful)

Shit hairline

Has his ex wife's name tattooed on his neck

Failed at his first marriage so badly that he resorted to marrying an anorexic bimbo

Only significant achievement was accidentally being booked to have a Wrestlemania streak

Is the wrestling equivalent of that one insufferably mediocre middle manager whose sole professional """""""achievement"""""" is staying in the same shitty job for 25 years

Drew so poorly in his 1997 title run that Bret Hart of all people had to take the belt off him

spent the latter part of his career burying superior young talent

The biggest impact he had on the business was sitting around in the back and telling one of his no-draw buddies to job to someone who could actually draw a dime
 
Undertaker

Never the guy

Never drew a dime

Never had a good match before 2006 and even then was carried by vastly superior workers

Never cut a memorable promo

Never put anyone over

Never had the balls to step out his WWF comfort even when Ted Turner threw millions at him

Main evented the lowest drawing Wrestlemania of the '90s

Main evented the lowest drawing Wrestlemania of the '10s

Tanked the buyrate of King Of The Ring in 2002 so hard the PPV got cancelled

Was barely ever in the main title picture because he was never a big enough deal

Only the 2nd best member of The Brothers of Destruction

Only the 4th best member of The Ministry

Only the 8th best member of The Corporate Ministry

His backstage clique "The Bone Street Krew" was utterly BTFO by The Kliq and achieved nothing notable except inflicting Savio Vega on us

His biker cosplay was cringeworthy

His MMA cosplay was cringeworthy

Unironically calls himself """"""""DA BEST PURE STRIKER IN DA WWE""""""""

Shit taste in whiskey (this one is actually 100% true, JD is awful)

Shit hairline

Has his ex wife's name tattooed on his neck

Failed at his first marriage so badly that he resorted to marrying an anorexic bimbo

Only significant achievement was accidentally being booked to have a Wrestlemania streak

Is the wrestling equivalent of that one insufferably mediocre middle manager whose sole professional """""""achievement"""""" is staying in the same shitty job for 25 years

Drew so poorly in his 1997 title run that Bret Hart of all people had to take the belt off him

spent the latter part of his career burying superior young talent

The biggest impact he had on the business was sitting around in the back and telling one of his no-draw buddies to job to someone who could actually draw a dime
So you like the guy...
 
None.

Wrestling doesn't exist without any of them
 
None.

Wrestling doesn't exist without any of them
Wrestling exists without all of them. But if we’re talking wrestling as it existed in the 80’s and 90’s, it isn’t the same without Hogan and Austin.

Without Hogan, the nWo never gets that kind of heat they got from the audience. WCW would’ve found a way to screw the Outsiders angle up pretty quickly. Hulk going heel and playing it to the hilt the way he did put the nWo, WCW, and wrestling into another stratosphere.

Austin similarly propelled WWF into the Attitude Era. Without Austin, the WWF would’ve folded and gotten gobbled up by WCW. HBK and Hart, as amazing as they were, weren’t huge draws. Nor was the Undertaker. Austin single-handedly saved that company from extinction, and people like the Rock were able to follow that anti-hero template Austin laid out and propel themselves and the WWF to eventual supremacy in the wrestling world.

Not shitting on the Rock with that statement. I actually preferred him to Austin as a kid. But Austin saved that fucking company.
 
Wrestling exists without all of them. But if we’re talking wrestling as it existed in the 80’s and 90’s, it isn’t the same without Hogan and Austin.

Without Hogan, the nWo never gets that kind of heat they got from the audience. WCW would’ve found a way to screw the Outsiders angle up pretty quickly. Hulk going heel and playing it to the hilt the way he did put the nWo, WCW, and wrestling into another stratosphere.

Austin similarly propelled WWF into the Attitude Era. Without Austin, the WWF would’ve folded and gotten gobbled up by WCW. HBK and Hart, as amazing as they were, weren’t huge draws. Nor was the Undertaker. Austin single-handedly saved that company from extinction, and people like the Rock were able to follow that anti-hero template Austin laid out and propel themselves and the WWF to eventual supremacy in the wrestling world.

Not shitting on the Rock with that statement. I actually preferred him to Austin as a kid. But Austin saved that fucking company.
Vince and Austin both saved it. Austin alone would have been huge but feuding with Vince strapped the GOAT rocket to his back.
 
Undertaker

Never the guy

Never drew a dime

Never had a good match before 2006 and even then was carried by vastly superior workers

Never cut a memorable promo

Never put anyone over

Never had the balls to step out his WWF comfort even when Ted Turner threw millions at him

Main evented the lowest drawing Wrestlemania of the '90s

Main evented the lowest drawing Wrestlemania of the '10s

Tanked the buyrate of King Of The Ring in 2002 so hard the PPV got cancelled

Was barely ever in the main title picture because he was never a big enough deal

Only the 2nd best member of The Brothers of Destruction

Only the 4th best member of The Ministry

Only the 8th best member of The Corporate Ministry

His backstage clique "The Bone Street Krew" was utterly BTFO by The Kliq and achieved nothing notable except inflicting Savio Vega on us

His biker cosplay was cringeworthy

His MMA cosplay was cringeworthy

Unironically calls himself """"""""DA BEST PURE STRIKER IN DA WWE""""""""

Shit taste in whiskey (this one is actually 100% true, JD is awful)

Shit hairline

Has his ex wife's name tattooed on his neck

Failed at his first marriage so badly that he resorted to marrying an anorexic bimbo

Only significant achievement was accidentally being booked to have a Wrestlemania streak

Is the wrestling equivalent of that one insufferably mediocre middle manager whose sole professional """""""achievement"""""" is staying in the same shitty job for 25 years

Drew so poorly in his 1997 title run that Bret Hart of all people had to take the belt off him

spent the latter part of his career burying superior young talent

The biggest impact he had on the business was sitting around in the back and telling one of his no-draw buddies to job to someone who could actually draw a dime
You really got a thing for this guy, huh?
 
Definitely Mark McCool. I feel little nostalgia for him and when I've watched his matches as an adult... meh.
 
You guys have never seen this before? It’s one of the best pastas ever

It’s actually extremely hurtful and borders on hate speech and I’d like you to delete it.
 
Sorry bud I don’t work for AEW


giphy.webp
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,237,102
Messages
55,467,731
Members
174,786
Latest member
plasterby
Back
Top