Submitting a Nogueira, especially in the weakest division, is not on par with beating a UFC washout in Eiji and a barely-UFC caliber fighter in Mac Danzig. In the deepest division. Cerrone, Pettis, Alvarez, Melendez are you kidding me?
Chael Sonnen getting a shot is the only questionable title shot TC mentioned. Edgar defended the toughest belt, multiple times, and is coming off a ROBBERY two weight classes above where he should be fighting.
Here's a fact: Gomi never did a thing in the UFC barring Tyson Griffin to even hint he was top 25 in the division. Other people have had entire fighting careers in the time since Gomi was champion level. It'd be like having Murilo Bustamante beat Jared Hamman for a shot at Anderson Silva. What's the point of having modern rankings if you're only gonna look at ones from freaking PRIDE?