Alan Wake
Played it back when it came out. I remember liking it, but I don't think I made it all that far. Anyways, it's on Game Pass, so I decided to give it a whirl. It still looks pretty good. There's some blocky textures, and the character models are a little stiff compared to what we get now, but considering it's age everything looks pretty good. The atmosphere is great as well, as the world feels very Twin Peaks-ish
The gameplay on the other hand...not so sure. I'm only two chapters in, so I won't judge it too harshly yet, but so far it's been very repetitive and basic. The chapter begins, the story is set up, you talk to some people, and then something happens that has you wandering out into the wilderness in the dark, where you will face off with groups of three or four enemies, kill them, and walk forward until you hit the next encounter. You basically do that all the way to the goal, with some "mini-bosses" thrown in there, who are basically normal enemies with bigger health bars. There is a cool light/shadow element to the combat, where your main weapon is a flashlight(or flares) and you shine it enemies to weaken them, and then finish them off with a gun. It's neat the first few times, but the novelty wears off really quickly.
That's about all I can say so far. Good atmosphere, interesting story, decent interactive environment when you're just walking around, but the gameplay itself leaves a lot to be desired. At least so far, anyways.