I appreciate the work you've done but if you're using Fight Matrix then it already isn't an exact science and we aren't using official historical rankings, so there should be room for applying common sense and context in order to mitigate some of the inherent problems with Fight Matrix. The problem with Fight Matrix here is that it's a retroactive formulaic ranking that's only searchable in 3 month increments. With Arona, the increments fall before his Wand win (when it ranks him #12) and after his blowout loss to Shogun (when it ranks him #5). Ipso facto we can conclude that Fight Matrix -- if their retroactive rankings were generated fight by fight rather than once every 3 months -- would rank Arona at least #5 for the Shogun fight
And this would align with the reality of where the consensus MMA community had Arona ranked when he fought Shogun. Arona was in fact the lineal Pride MW champ at that point, of course he was ranked top 10. Ignoring this, as well as the fact that Fight Matrix had Arona #5 after losing to Shogun, and instead insisting that it had Arona #12 on 07/01/2005 prior to his Wand and Shogun fights, would just be doubling down on the limitations of using Fight Matrix in the first place
#4 Sokoudjou
Jesus, the people responsible for that ranking should be ashamed of themselves. Quick KO's of Arona and Lil' nog shouldn't have got him this high.

I appreciate the work you've done but if you're using Fight Matrix then it already isn't an exact science and we aren't using official historical rankings, so there should be room for applying common sense and context in order to mitigate some of the inherent problems with Fight Matrix. The problem with Fight Matrix here is that it's a retroactive formulaic ranking that's only searchable in 3 month increments. With Arona, the increments fall before his Wand win (when it ranks him #12) and after his blowout loss to Shogun (when it ranks him #5). Ipso facto we can conclude that Fight Matrix -- if their retroactive rankings were generated fight by fight rather than once every 3 months -- would rank Arona at least #5 for the Shogun fight
And this would align with the reality of where the consensus MMA community had Arona ranked when he fought Shogun. Arona was in fact the lineal Pride MW champ at that point, of course he was ranked top 10. Ignoring this, as well as the fact that Fight Matrix had Arona #5 after losing to Shogun, and instead insisting that it had Arona #12 on 07/01/2005 prior to his Wand and Shogun fights, would just be doubling down on the limitations of using Fight Matrix in the first place
Nogueira was #3 and Arona was #4 when they lost to Sokoudjou, so what's so strange about him then getting bumped up to #4? Lesnar got bumped up to #2 after his 4th fight in MMA <Lmaoo>.I didn't mean to imply the method of victory should make a difference, I meant that beating those two at all should have gotten him to #4
To answer in a general sense: it's likely either due to a fighter getting removed from the rankings due to inactivity or just not being ranked top ten at the time of the fight.Why do some fighters like Chuck get rematches counted but Jones and Dc dont?
#4 Sokoudjou
Jesus, the people responsible for that ranking should be ashamed of themselves. Quick KO's of Arona and Lil' nog shouldn't have got him this high.
Yeah bro keep up the good work @acannxr
Man this dude aint got all goddamn day. Throw him some money !I like these threads, but I think you should source more than one set of rankings. Fight matrix has it's flaws.
Get your totals right buddy. Jon fought Gus 2x not once. Same with DCThe Lightweight version is here.
The Welterweight version is here.
The Middleweight version is here.
Rankings are based on FightMatrix.
Frank Shamrock
![]()
Shamrock's resume:
#4 Kevin Jackson
#1 Tito Ortiz
Shamrock has 2 top ten wins.
Jan Błachowicz
![]()
Błachowicz' resume:
#7 Corey Anderson
#7 Dominick Reyes
Błachowicz has 2 top ten wins.
Forrest Griffin
![]()
Griffin's resume:
#2 Mauricio Rua
#1 Quinton Jackson
#10 Rich Franklin
Griffin has 3 top ten wins.
Vitor Belfort
![]()
Belfort's resume:
#5 Wanderlei Silva
#1 Randy Couture
#9 Dan Henderson
Belfort has 3 top ten wins.
Randy Couture
![]()
Couture's resume:
#2 Chuck Liddell
#2 Tito Ortiz
#2 Vitor Belfort
Couture has 3 top ten wins.
Daniel Cormier
![]()
Cormier's resume:
#5 Dan Henderson
#2 Anthony Johnson
#7 Alexander Gustafsson
#3 Anthony Johnson
#7 Volkan Oezdemir
Cormier has 5 top ten wins.
Dan Henderson
![]()
Henderson's resume:
#10 Murilo Bustamante
#8 Yuki Kondo
#10 Vitor Belfort
#9 Rich Franklin
#2 Mauricio Rua
#9 Mauricio Rua
Henderson has 6 top ten wins.
Wanderlei Silva
![]()
Silva's resume:
#7 Kazushi Sakuraba
#6 Quinton Jackson
#7 Yuki Kondo
#4 Quinton Jackson
#5 Ricardo Arona
#3 Keith Jardine
Silva has 6 top ten wins.
Tito Ortiz
![]()
Ortiz' resume:
#6 Jerry Bohlander
#8 Wanderlei Silva
#1 Yuki Kondo
#9 Evan Tanner
#6 Vladimir Matyushenko
#3 Vitor Belfort
#9 Ryan Bader
Ortiz has 7 top ten wins.
Lyoto Machida
![]()
Machida's resume:
#4 Sokoudjou
#9 Tito Ortiz
#2 Rashad Evans
#4 Mauricio Rua
#7 Randy Couture
#6 Ryan Bader
#4 Dan Henderson
Machida has 7 top ten wins.
Rashad Evans
![]()
Evans' resume:
#2 Chuck Liddell
#1 Forrest Griffin
#10 Thiago Silva
#2 Quinton Jackson
#10 Phil Davis
#3 Dan Henderson
#8 Chael Sonnen
Evans has 7 top ten wins.
Quinton Jackson
![]()
Jackson's resume:
#5 Kevin Randleman
#3 Chuck Liddell
#1 Chuck Liddell
#5 Dan Henderson
#4 Wanderlei Silva
#7 Keith Jardine
#3 Lyoto Machida
Jackson has 7 top ten wins.
Chuck Liddell
![]()
Liddell's resume:
#6 Paul Jones
#9 Murilo Bustamante
#5 Tito Ortiz
#1 Randy Couture
#3 Randy Couture
#8 Renato Sobral
#6 Tito Ortiz
#9 Wanderlei Silva
Liddell has 8 top ten wins.
Mauricio Rua
![]()
Rua's resume:
#5 Quinton Jackson
#8 Antonio Rogerio Nogueira
#5 Alistair Overeem
#10 Alistair Overeem
#8 Chuck Liddell
#1 Lyoto Machida
#6 Forrest Griffin
#10 Antonio Rogerio Nogueira
Rua has 8 top ten wins.
Jon Jones
![]()
Jones' resume:
#6 Ryan Bader
#1 Mauricio Rua
#4 Quinton Jackson
#6 Lyoto Machida
#3 Rashad Evans
#4 Alexander Gustafsson
#6 Glover Teixeira
#2 Daniel Cormier
#4 Anthony Smith
#6 Thiago Santos
#8 Dominick Reyes
Jones has 11 top ten wins.
Gustafsson wasn't ranked in the rematch due to inactivity; the rematch with Cormier isn't a win for Jones, it's a no contest.Get your totals right buddy. Jon fought Gus 2x not once. Same with DC

Probably due to him having just defeated Shogun in their rematch.Hendo was ranked when Cormier beat him? Damnnnnn
Source or you're lyingGustafsson wasn't ranked in the rematch due to inactivity; the rematch with Cormier isn't a win for Jones, it's a no contest.
![]()
I appreciate the work you've done but if you're using Fight Matrix then it already isn't an exact science and we aren't using official historical rankings, so there should be room for applying common sense and context in order to mitigate some of the inherent problems with Fight Matrix. The problem with Fight Matrix here is that it's a retroactive formulaic ranking that's only searchable in 3 month increments. With Arona, the increments fall before his Wand win (when it ranks him #12) and after his blowout loss to Shogun (when it ranks him #5). Ipso facto we can conclude that Fight Matrix -- if their retroactive rankings were generated fight by fight rather than once every 3 months -- would rank Arona at least #5 for the Shogun fight
And this would align with the reality of where the consensus MMA community had Arona ranked when he fought Shogun. Arona was in fact the lineal Pride MW champ at that point, of course he was ranked top 10. Ignoring this, as well as the fact that Fight Matrix had Arona #5 after losing to Shogun, and instead insisting that it had Arona #12 on 07/01/2005 prior to his Wand and Shogun fights, would just be doubling down on the limitations of using Fight Matrix in the first place