- Joined
- Aug 23, 2011
- Messages
- 2,613
- Reaction score
- 1,137
YesI only know her from Black Panther, but I don’t know which character she was supposed to be. Was she Black Panther’s love interest, his sister, his mom or his Captain of the guard?
YesI only know her from Black Panther, but I don’t know which character she was supposed to be. Was she Black Panther’s love interest, his sister, his mom or his Captain of the guard?
In your estimation of history, were the greeks more aware of Northeast Africa or Britain?Nothing bizarre about it. But I get pretending to not understand things is the extent of discourse for you and your tribe.
Yeah, Greek myths. If there was a movie based on a Nubian myth from the same era an important mortal female character sure as heck would not be played by a white actress.Again, Mansa Musa is a real historical figure. Oppenheimer is a real person.
Those in the Odyssey are not and were even considered mostly mythological by the Greeks when they got around to writing down later versions of the story.
Then why aren't you complaining about Tom Holland being in the movie?Yeah, Greek myths. If there was a movie based on a Nubian myth from the same era an important mortal female character sure as heck would not be played by a white actress.
It is sold to an American and Euro audience first and foremost. The cast will speak in English they will be dubbed for certain markets.Then why aren't you complaining about Tom Holland being in the movie?
It's far more likely that an African would be involved in Greek history during this time period than a dude from Britain.
Let alone an actor from Colombia.
All I see so far is people clutching pearls that a director known for casting actors they like in films that tend to skew away from historical fact cast a black women in an unclear role in an unreleased movie that will probably be typical Nolan fare.
They were more aware of white looking Thracians and Macedonians / proto Macedonians than Nubians.In your estimation of history, were the greeks more aware of Northeast Africa or Britain?
so see how this person is trying to pretend he doesn't understand what's going on with Hollywood casting?In your estimation of history, were the greeks more aware of Northeast Africa or Britain?
Again, I have no problems with an adaptation of a myth not being perfectly accurate if identity is not intrinsic to a character and depending on how the adaptation is positioned.
It's telling that you're only complaining about Lupita's casting, rather than Tom Holland or John Leguizamo. Last I checked the Greeks knew about Northeast Africa and to a lesser extent Britain. They certainly didn't know about Colombia.
All of those are historical figures. The characters and the events in the Homerian epics are not.
How dense are you that you think Homer's works are anything but fiction with a small sprinkling of history?
Again, you might as well whine whenever school plays adapt Romeo and Juliet and the cast isn't Italian.
You also never answered directly here. I take it it's because you didn't know?
You also appear very unaware that Ethiopia is literally in Homer's works.
He is. It's literally all he's been educated in. How to argue dishonestly. All of his tribe is like this. Waste of time to engage in good faith with themNot sure if you are being deliberately dishonest or not. You keep failing to understand that a myth can still be grounded in a specific and real time and place, like the Mycenean GREEK period, and its a specific Greek tale not a generic myth. It has nothing to do whether the characters were real or not. Ethiopa is also irrelevant, and just a deflection as it was a specific Greek tale with Greek characters literally set in the Greek Kingdom.
It still fun to strip them of arguments and leave them only with ad hominem.He is. It's literally all he's been educated in. How to argue dishonestly. All of his tribe is like this. Waste of time to engage in good faith with them
Depending on their skill I agree lolIt still fun to strip them of arguments and leave them only with ad hominem.