• Xenforo is upgrading us to version 2.3.7 on Tuesday Aug 19, 2025 at 01:00 AM BST (date has been pushed). This upgrade includes several security fixes among other improvements. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

Locked THE MANDALORIAN Season 1

Status
Not open for further replies.
Canon re-writing is the norm now.
Yeah, I was just saying that’s what it would take to say they are. Apparently Geroge’s words and wisdom don’t carry the weight they used to, lol.
 
How do people like The Mandalorian not know who the fuck the Jedi are?

They were generals in the clone Wars. They've fought mandalorian...how would he have no clue about them?

Big galaxy?

But seriously, in the Revenge of the Sith novelization, it talked about how Anakin was the face of the Republic. His exploits were all over the Holonet. He was the "hero without fear". Him and Obiwan were so famous that children squabbled over who would win in a fight.
 
Yeah, I was just saying that’s what it would take to say they are. Apparently Geroge’s words and wisdom don’t carry the weight they used to, lol.

George might as well be posting on Sherdog with the rest of us, that's as much he's listened to lol.
 
George might as well be posting on Sherdog with the rest of us, that's as much he's listened to lol.
Some of the responses I’ve seen in threads make me wonder if he is.
 
How do people like The Mandalorian not know who the fuck the Jedi are?

They were generals in the clone Wars. They've fought mandalorian...how would he have no clue about them?


10,000 Jedi in a galaxy of 50 million inhabited systems.

Jedi being the focus of the movies does not mean they were the focus of the galaxy.
 
Jango was taking his helmet off all over the place, though it's possible Jango was a Mando at one point. Boba was his clone and didn't seem to have connection with the Mandos other than the armor. But they can always change that.

The helmet thing is a new development in Mandalorian culture. The Rebels series ended at around the time of The Battle of Endor (Return of the Jedi). THis series is something like 7 years later and theres been some sort of "purge" of Mandalorians since Rebels. During Rebels Mandos had their helmets off all the time.
 
10,000 Jedi in a galaxy of 50 million inhabited systems.

Jedi being the focus of the movies does not mean they were the focus of the galaxy.
You would think their exploits would be pretty well known.

Maybe sidious forbid any discussion of them and they just fell out of memory.
 
Also, LOL at anyone reading too much in to the force choke episode. By then he had bonded with his father figure and Mando had saved him and he was just protecting his father figure from what he mistook as Cara trying to harm his Daddy O.
 
Jango was taking his helmet off all over the place, though it's possible Jango was a Mando at one point. Boba was his clone and didn't seem to have connection with the Mandos other than the armor. But they can always change that.
And the Mandolorians in Rebels were always taking off their helmets. Really silly thing to invent at this stage.
 
10,000 Jedi in a galaxy of 50 million inhabited systems.

Jedi being the focus of the movies does not mean they were the focus of the galaxy.
Han thought the force and Jedi was a bunch of nonsense in EpIV and that was only about 16 years after the Jedi were eradicated
 
You would think their exploits would be pretty well known.

Maybe sidious forbid any discussion of them and they just fell out of memory.


They are well known. I mean, Mando has met like 10 people and a couple of them know about "such things" or have heard "the stories".
 
Man, season 2 better have more of Bill Burr.

"This twat put me in prison. Can you believe this momo? I'll have his balls mounted on my wall. This fucking guy..."
 
You are being really overcritical. Resistance cartoon really stinks. No real interesting or likeable characters or stories. Mando has Mando, Baby Yoda, IG-11, Kuiil, and even Apollo is a bit likeable. Ming Na Wen has to come back and be interesting.

The CGI Clone Wars cartoon was offputting because of the snooty characters, shitty stories, too much political talkie talk, everyone is equal including clones.

Mandalorian has parts that seem hard to believe, but as a whole, it's the best presentation of anything Star Wars in a long time.
Everyone always tells me I'm being overly critical, and then a season or two later they're forced to accept I was ahead of the curve. Happened with Dexter and The Walking Dead.

Clone Wars giving the clones deeper characterization and attentiveness is exactly what set it apart. It's vastly superior to this series. Sure, there are likeable characters, and the overall thrust of plot is well crafted, but the execution is so clumsy and mindlessly forced that it renders this stuff obsolete. It's succumbing to maudlin sap, now, too. When the series started it looked like Disney was going to manage the extraordinary feat of creating a gritty series that was still family friendly. That mirage has evaporated.

It's astonishing to me how production value pulls the wool over people's eyes. Petey was right. This series is Hercules or Xena: Warrior Princess set in the Star Wars universe.
 
It wasn’t clean because an enemy helped him. He did right by Yoda and they are no longer enemies. They’re a tribe of two. Their first kill together now works well as a signet.
She should have gave him a Jawa signet after all the Jawas Mando vaporized with his rifle.
 
Everyone always tells me I'm being overly critical, and then a season or two later they're forced to accept I was ahead of the curve. Happened with Dexter and The Walking Dead.

Clone Wars giving the clones deeper characterization and attentiveness is exactly what set it apart. It's vastly superior to this series. Sure, there are likeable characters, and the overall thrust of plot is well crafted, but the execution is so clumsy and mindlessly forced that it renders this stuff obsolete. It's succumbing to maudlin sap, now, too. When the series started it looked like Disney was going to manage the extraordinary feat of creating a gritty series that was still family friendly. That mirage has evaporated.

It's astonishing to me how production value pulls the wool over people's eyes. Petey was right. This series is Hercules or Xena: Warrior Princess set in the Star Wars universe.
Eat a Snickers bar. You're one of the few contrarians. Everyone else all over the internet likes Mandalorian. I saw an article that said Rotten Tomato gave it a 100%, which I'm assuming is good and rare.

If you were the Disney CEO, we'd get nothing. You'd cancel Mandalorian Season 2. Equating Mandalorian to dog shit Resistance was really over the top bonkers. No one bought Resistance action figures and they were marked down for clearance. Everyone's wanting Mandalorian and Baby Yoda toys.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top