- Joined
- Oct 20, 2007
- Messages
- 6,699
- Reaction score
- 12,566
Shit, jazz is the fucking best. It took me a bit to get into, you owe it to yourself to give it a good try. Once it clicked I was absolutely hooked.
I agree. I do like some jazz. But often times the musicians are so into the musicianship of the song, and making sure they do some kind of cool polyrhythm and mode change, that they lose sight of the concept of writing a good song. You know, one that actually sounds good.
It’s masturbatory bullshit a lot of times.
You’re back...
You can’t refute that because you know exactly nothing about music. You stated one of the stupidest things I have ever read on sherdog.
“Jazz has no structure”
The very tip of the iceberg, follow the link and educate yourself.
To begin your study of rhythm changes, you look at the form for this important jazz structure.
https://mattwarnockguitar.com/rhythm-changes/#form
Now for everyone’s sake, toss your computer out the window. You’re literally making the world a stupider place.
Cinc, homes, I don’t know if you know this, but I am a highly accomplished musician (feel free to ask waigen, he asked me to send him a clip of my playing, in his words, I am “elite level”).
I am a multi-instrumentalist, and have studied classical and jazz at the highest levels. Jazz is every bit as sophisticated as classical music, and in fact FAR more harmonically and melodically complex than practically anything pre, late romantic era.
Honestly, the problem is you can’t “hear it”. It takes about a decade of work to actually reach the point where you understand what you’re hearing. To give you an idea, I was an accomplished classical player (performing Bach fugues for instance), had years of theory and ear training under my belt, and it still took me a solid 5 years of several hours a Day work (between 2-6) to truly be able to hear it.
Make no mistake, John Coltrane is every bit the musician as Mozart.
Jazz does not have structure. Jazz musicians will say that the structure is formed by the interplay of the musicians. But it doesn't help the listener, if they don't understand what is taking place.
Classical music, as an alternative, is strict and structured to sound the same each time. It's a better listening experience for the listener.
I've always liked this one