NFL The Great Aaron Rodgers

[Sir Elzio Dennick]

4 time NFL MVP.

Top 4 or higher in every QB stat that matters.

Obvious Hall of Famer and joins Brady, Montana and Peyton on that NFL QB Mount Rushmore

Anyone disagree?

 

[Sir Elzio Dennick]

Hold it....

Someday Mahomes will own all the QB records so I migth wanna wait before chiseling out a Mount Rushmore.

 

[Sir Elzio Dennick]

Right now talking today

Rodgers

Comp% 66.8 Mahomes 64.6
TD/INT 18/7 Mahomes 17/5
Passer Rating 97.2 Mahomes 98.2

 

[JackWhite]

Easily top 5, IMO.

Brady, Montana, Mahomes, Manning, Rodgers.

 

[Yoricks Wisdom]

Needs more hallucinogenic toads IMO.

 

['Rocky']

It's obviously Elway, Marino, Manning, Rodgers

Only casuals who just look at espn stats think Brady or Mahomes are great imo

 

[Madmick]

Only casuals who just look at espn stats think Brady or Mahomes are great imo

Well, and all the NFL players themselves who vote on that every year.
And the coaches and scouts who are also occasionally polled.
And all the pundits (many of whom are former players and coaches) at the major news networks, on radio shows, hosting podcasts, and so on.
And all the career sports journalists and football historians who spend their entire lives immersed in the NFL and its culture, and write books on the topic.
And the vast majority of "hardcore" fans who fritter their lives away sucking at fantasy sports, and delude themselves into this belief that total armchair viewing hours somehow hold any value of expertise or special insight despite that any correlation therein remains entirely untested, unproven, and most importantly untethered to any force that would necessarily improve & correct their opinions when wrong as it relates to actually winning football games (the entire point of competition).

But only them.

 

['Rocky']

Well, and all the NFL players themselves who vote on that every year.
And the coaches and scouts who are also occasionally polled.
And all the pundits (many of whom are former players and coaches) at the major news networks, on radio shows, hosting podcasts, and so on.
And all the career sports journalists and football historians who spend their entire lives immersed in the NFL and its culture, and write books on the topic.
And the vast majority of "hardcore" fans who fritter their lives away sucking at fantasy sports and delude themselves into this belief that total armchair viewing hours somehow hold any value of expertise or special insight despite that any correlation therein remains entirely untested, unproven, and most importantly untethered to any force that would necessarily improve & correct their opinions when wrong as it related to actually winning football games (the entire point of competition).

But only them.

Spoiler

 

[Sir Elzio Dennick]

It's obviously Elway, Marino, Manning, Rodgers

Only casuals who just look at espn stats think Brady or Mahomes are great imo

Make a case for Elway and Marino over Brady and Mahomes, I gotta see this,

 

[Madmick]

Spoiler

 

['Rocky']

Make a case for Elway and Marino over Brady and Mahomes, I gotta see this,

Elway and Marino weren't surrounded by teams that made them look better than they are and also weren't caught cheating or having refs rig games for them. Lol

 

[Sir Elzio Dennick]

Elway and Marino weren't surrounded by teams that made them look better than they are and also weren't caught cheating or having refs rig games for them. Lol

So on your top 10 QB list you have Elway and Marino above Brady and Mahomes, riight?

 

['Rocky']

So on your top 10 QB list you have Elway and Marino above Brady and Mahomes, riight?

No. I have Elway and Marino on the actual list.

 

[Sir Elzio Dennick]

No. I have Elway and Marino on the actual list.

Ok so.....

Both Brady amd Mahomes have won how many SB combared to Elway and Marino?
Brady and Mahomes both won two NFL MVP's, Elway and Marino one a piece

Now looking at comp%, TD/NT ratio, Passer rating its lal Brady and Mahomes not close at all.

Brady is number one in TD passes number one in yards, Mahomes will pass both Marino and Elway in time.

What are you looking at, it's not playoff succes, not stats, not personal accomplishments, so............?????

 

['Rocky']

Ok so.....

Both Brady amd Mahomes have won how many SB combared to Elway and Marino?
Brady and Mahomes both won two NFL MVP's, Elway and Marino one a piece

Now looking at comp%, TD/NT ratio, Passer rating its lal Brady and Mahomes not close at all.

Brady is number one in TD passes number one in yards, Mahomes will pass both Marino and Elway in time.

What are you looking at, it's not playoff succes, not stats, not personal accomplishments, so............?????

Elway and Marino would have won all the Super Bowls if they swapped teams with Brady and Mahomo....... so........ ?????

 

[Sir Elzio Dennick]

Elway and Marino would have won all the Super Bowls if they swapped teams with Brady and Mahomo....... so........ ?????

Nobody cares about some fantasy ok fica, Let's deal in what actually happened, ok? Ya know.....reality.

Brady and Mahomes were FAR more successful than Marino and Elways, they had far beTter numbers, ok?

Dude, real ife has Brady and Mahomes shitting all over Elway and Marino, FACT~~~~~~~~~~~~~

 

[Sir Elzio Dennick]

Nobody cares about some fantasy ok fica, Let's deal in what actually happened, ok? Ya know.....reality.

Brady and Mahomes were FAR more successful than Marino and Elways, they had far beTter numbers, ok?

Dude, real ife has Brady and Mahomes shitting all over Elway and Marino, FACT~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Good choice, actual accomplishments/stats SCREAM Brady and Mahomes far better QB;s than Elway and Marino .

 

[Sir Elzio Dennick]

I;m holding off on posting those hard cold facts, trust me Elway and Marino on a totally lesser level actually comical to be honest.

Tom Brady won what six or was it seven SB;s, Marino...............................................................................................0

And don;t lay that lame ass, well if he had played, fuck that BS,

John Unitas had a Hall of Fame left tackle, TE, WR, RB, nobody ever.....if not for Jim Parler John Mackey, Ray Berry and Lenny More he ain't shit.

 

[Pittie Petey]

I once sat in front of Aaron Rodgers at a UFC event, I was in the front row aisle seat and the camera man was standing next to me and filming behind me so I turned around to take a look and saw someone setting right behind me that I knew was famous but I was so dang shitface drunk that I couldnt figure out who the heck it was

I just set there staring right at him for way too long, cause I was so drunk, so I'm sure he was getting kind of uncomfortable at this weirdo all up in his grill LoL

Wasnt til the next day when I sobered up that I remembered who he was

One thing that doesnt come across on tv is how massive his head is, he has a huge giant caveman jaw, I'm talking like Jay Leno jaw, it doesnt look that way on the ole boob tube, though

 

[Sir Elzio Dennick]

I once sat in front of Aaron Rodgers at a UFC event, I was in the front row aisle seat and the camera man was standing next to me and filming behind me so I turned around to take a look and saw someone setting right behind me that I knew was famous but I was so dang shitface drunk that I couldnt figure out who the heck it was

I just set there staring right at him for way too long, cause I was so drunk, so I'm sure he was getting kind of uncomfortable at this weirdo all up in his grill LoL

Wasnt til the next day when I sobered up that I remembered who he was

One thing that doesnt come across on tv is how massive his head is, he has a huge giant caveman jaw, I'm talking like Jay Leno jaw, it doesnt look that way on the ole boob tube, though

Cool story.

Speaking of a big head, OJ Simpson. I saw him in Fresno at a track meet, his SFCC days, talk about a weird look, how his neck held that up....???