- Joined
- Mar 3, 2014
- Messages
- 57,509
- Reaction score
- 21,595
Anyways, I agree with kpt that homophobia =/= opposition to gay marriage. However, I also acknowledge that outright homophobia is prevalent in the black community. But I would disagree that homophobia is the hallmark of the deplorable sect.
Me too. But if we're looking at a Venn of this I'm certain there would be a Helluva an overlap in those viewpoints. So absent more accuate data (unless you've got some?), it's a pretty damn good starting point to put us in the ballpark.
I don't think it's necessarily a hallmark. But she used it as an example of what makes one deplorable so I challenged it. I took her quote to mean that any one of those things lands you in the category, not that you had to be all of them.
I'm not denying there is a connection between hostility and disallowing of rights. I'm just pointing out that isn't the only possibility. There are plenty of religious folks that don't hate gays, per se, but don't want them to have the right to marry. I find that view to be terrible as well, but it doesn't have to be out of hate.
I don't think falling back on your religious views is a good reason to fight to keep gays from getting married.
In this conversation, what exactly does liking or disliking SSM and/or homosexuals entail? For me, it's just about them having equal rights and being free to be happy and productive. I don't like or dislike of anyone based on sexual preference. Do you mean that you find it gross? That's fine, it's your reaction, but it's not a good reason to govern one way or another.
That's fine. But as I say to Trotsky up above, it's as reliable of an indicator as any I could find data for. And I didn't really think my point couldn't be made without pinpointing it down to within +/- 3%.
Nice that we agree on leaving religion at the door when it comes to governance.
I don't exactly what it entails because Hilary didn't really specify. And since she probably didn't collect stats on hate crimes against gays (and break them down by political affiliation), I went off my best guess that she was referring to poll results on gay marriage. What do you think she was defining homophobia as and what data was she using to base any sort of comment on that insinuates that attitude is more prevalent in the other guy's supporters? Impossible to know at this point really.
What's important here is she cast aspersions on tens of millions of people with nothing of substance to back it up. Some will call that intuitive and support her. Some will not be happy that she's condemning the character of their friends an family members who they know to be Trump supporters. Bottom line, I don't see how it was either fair or smart to make such an inflammatory claim.
I never said this was the only or most important part of the "deplorables" paragraph.
I didn't mean to imply that you did. But I did take your post to mean that disliking gays was both horrific and awful, based on those words being used. Is that not correct?