Thoughts on Berserk
I had never read any manga before, and had not watched any anime in many years. Did not watch much even back then.
Had learned the basic plot of Berserk, and heard that it was generally considered the best example of manga, so wanted to give it a try.
Over the past few months, read all of it, up to the last chapter completed by Miura.
I realize I am an ignorant n00b compared to everyone else in this thread, but would appreciate any feedback.
The Good:
-The Golden Age Arc is fantastic. Enjoyed almost every aspect. Very memorable, exciting, touching. Would highly recommend to others.
-The Black Swordsman Arc is a bit over-the-top in its edginess and horror elements, but still is fun
The Bad
-The other Arcs are not particularly good.
-Guts seems to become more myth than man. He is nearly unbeatable in combat, which detracts from the suspense. His character development is minimal, and even his dialogue is scant. His old comrades are dead, and he cannot meaningfully interact with Casca. The new companions meet view him as a mysterious powerful warrior, and after a while that is how the audience comes to see him.
-The The change in Puck to a comic shapeshifter feels forced and out of place
-The gratuitous violence and nudity reached a point of diminishing returns somewhere around the Conviction Arc and then started to have the opposite of the intended effect, becoming routine and tedious by the Fantasia Arc
-When Miura would return to focus on the three main characters, Guts, Griffith, and Casca, the series remained interesting, but this happened all too infrequently
Concerns:
-I worry that Miura did not truly have the entire plot mapped out for his team to complete, considering it took him so long to release the chapters that he did make
-I worry that he became uninterested in his original creation and his original intended direction
For the above reasons, not sure I will continue to read the series.
But I am very interested in the thoughts and experiences of others.